Welcome to Gaia! ::


Aged Seeker

10,450 Points
  • Alchemy Level 10 100
  • Unfortunate Abductee 175
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
Well THAT was embarrassing! HAHAHAHA Especially considering my FIELD!

Bad night, bad day, fatigue, mind bog, poor eyesight, memory dysfunction! Yes, YES! That was why!!!

I do appreciate you letting me know. I, too, welcome (and rely on) informative correction!
Submitted by: pingpong867

Title: Edge of the World - Rewrite



They always said that life was a battle that couldn't be won.

That's why I sit here, contemplating my life on this cold, hard ledge. If it couldn't be won, what was the use of living it? Though we toil and work all our days for that one beautiful look at the promised land, what does it get us? Souls that are chained and bound to our jobs and relationships always yearning to break free and forget about everything. Once this is accomplished, there will be the wonder of a new life free from the horrors of the world. The goal... the goal is still uncertain. Or maybe not so uncertain as it is vague. There is still the matter of the objective that has to be worked out.

I sought this spot on the edge of the world for both the solitude, and the possibility of release from my chains. I carefully poke and prod at my right side, where my ribs are. Wincing in pain, I shake me head and fight back the tears that threaten to come to my eyes. If nothing else, then I want to escape from my home. I can be free of the beatings and berating, and no longer feel any pain.

I laugh with contempt at the people scurrying a hundred feet below me. Do they even fathom that we need not live as we do? That life based solely upon work is not a life at all, but merely an existence tolerating repression by "leaders" and money? Probably not. Otherwise, they might be sitting up here with me. On the other hand, they haven't experienced what I have.

I have to choose if I want to stay or go. Of course I hesitate to make my decision. It is a difficult decision to make; one that, once made, cannot be withdrawn from. I absent-mindedly trace the swirling pattern on the ledge thinking of all the different ways I could have a better life, one not so horrible. But none come up that sound quite so freeing as the one I am currently examining.

Accidentally, I knock a small pebble over the ledge. I place myself into the mind of the pebble, until I can see and feel what it is going through. I lose sight of it before I can reach the ground, but I know that it falls and shatters into many shards, scattering across the pavement. Eventually the fragments will be ground into the cement by human feet until all that remains is dust in the wind. Do I want to become nothing but dust in the wind?

My pebble catches someone's attention. Who might that person be? A sympathizer? An idealistic subordinate on their way to work? Or perhaps only another passer-by, finding themselves pegged by a falling pebble. I hear a shout, and the person takes the cell phone of the person nearest them. A small crowd gathers.

Soon, I hear wailing sirens and see the flash of azure and scarlet lights. The police cars arrive at the scene, and my loyal fans are pushed away and forced to stand behind a barrier of yellow tape. Some barrier. I roll my eyes at the ridiculousness of the police in general.

"Please remain calm. We have an officer coming up there now. I repeat, please remain calm," a plump, cross looking gentleman in a most unbecoming uniform calls up to me over the megaphone. I shake my head, annoyed with these people who could not give me an hour to my thoughts.

I sit up there, then, conversing with the young officer they sent up after me. He's actually pretty good-looking, though I find him completely ignorant of everything that matters. He won't take the hint, though, and leave, even after I give him some obvious hints that I do not want him there. He'll never go away, of that I am sure. He is a persistent man. Tenacity is annoying.

Perhaps if I actually started listening to him, then he would leave. Maybe he'd be satisfied that he did his good turn for that day. Or maybe he'd just think I have Dissociative Identity Disorder... if he could comprehend what that was. Which he probably couldn't. This man is about as dumb as a mule, and as boring. Too bad all that handsomeness was wasted on a fool like him.

After a while, it begins to rain, and my knight in not-so-shiny armor decides that it is now up to me to make my own decision. This is not news to me. I knew that it was up to me a long time ago, before he began his inspirational speech. He only confirmed my thoughts that people are morons.

My fans departed a while ago, bound for their jobs and other prior obligations. "The-girl-who's-going-to-jump" isn't all that entertaining anymore. It'll make a story for over the water cooler, at least. It’ll be a mystery ending though… maybe it’ll be a direct-to-television movie that wins some sort of award. I guess I can dream.

The policeman continues to wait below, gazing up at me dejectedly from his squad car. He wants his speech to have made a positive impact on me. And maybe it has.

I'm beginning to think that humanity is too clueless to be without people like me. If I let go of this earth, then who would be there to stop all the oppression, the hurting? No one. I need to get these Homo sapiens back in touch with what is really happening. I guess my stunt did teach me something. It taught me I was too needed to let go.

Carefully, I scoot back from the ledge and stand, beginning to walk towards the steps that will lead me down to the bottom.

I think they might be wrong.


Author's Note: I worked on the character, her motivations, and some of the repetition. I tried to fix my jerky sentences and develop one smooth style, but that was harder for me. Both of my reviewers also said that they thought this was a very arrogant piece, so I changed the mood slightly so it was more self-pity than anything. And I corrected the one misspelled word.

Also, no I have never been there, Mahayr. Simply a work of my imagination.
Author and title: Damiascutlass - Hell Masked

Style: 3
-- Comments: see below.
Narrative: 4
-- Comments: see below.
Characters: 2
-- Comments: see below.
Grammar, etc: 4
-- Comments: see below.
Plot/originality: 4
-- Comments: see below.
Overall: 4
-- Comments: Don't let my nit-picking that follows fool you; I liked this story and enjoyed reading it. I could tell what was coming and dread the ending while still hoping for it to turn out better, without it feeling too predictable (narrative, plot/originality). My main problems with it were some awkward sentence constructions (style) and stilted dialogue (style, characters?). Keep in mind that these are all just my opinion. Since it's your story, your opinion is the one that counts.

And now, since I think numbers are useless:

Quote:
If through Grace and God she could survive through the night, perhaps she would be devout to God as she was meant to be.

Style: "Grace and God" sounds odd - did you maybe mean "the grace of God"? Or it could just be an expression I'm unfamiliar with.
Style: The "God [...] God" sounds a bit repetitive.
Character: Why was she meant to be devout?

Quote:
?party?

Grammar, style: I'm guessing the question marks are quotes that didn't show up; if they are, they aren't needed. Either it's a party or it isn't - if it isn't, tell us what it is.

Quote:
it was hoped by her to be true

Style: Normally I don't mind passive constructions, but this feels weak and awkward. Maybe something like "at least she hoped"?

Quote:
Her father, a fetish

Grammar: "fetishist"?

Quote:
the chandeliers graced only with the light of wax candles

Style: Sounds a bit awkward, like the chandeliers are the subject of the illumination.

Quote:
The men all wore old-fashioned suits, all seeming to suit the Victorian Age of England, the suits all dark and worn.

Style: Repetition of "all" and "suit".

Quote:
But, of course Fate wound its threads in a less desirable manner.

Style: The beginnings and ends of sentences are their strongest points - starting with a conjunction weakens them. I suggest "Fate, however, wound..." although some people dislike "however".

Quote:
The spiraling staircase wound up to the second floor, though candlelight was insufficient to find one?s way up it.

Style: "up it" is unnecessary and weakens the sentence.

Quote:
her ankles crossed on the marble ground, moist lines upon her face, slightly blackened by the old-fashioned make-up

Style, grammar: I'd recommend splitting these descriptive phrases up into separate sentences; they may also be dangling.

Quote:
whom had divorced her mother

Grammar: "who". Test: "He had divorced her mother," or "Him had divorced her mother."

Quote:
he could also be harsh and strange

Character, style: How is he harsh, and how is he strange?

Quote:
A soft hand trailed on her semi-bared shoulder

Narrative: I didn't immediately pick up that this was someone else's hand.

Quote:
Staring at the person who had smoothed their hand over her skin, played with her curl, her eyes hardened.

Grammar: "Their" is plural, so "his" might be better.

Quote:
?Fire eat your heart, and consume your soul, yet my flesh is not yours to claim. Do not dare try it.?

Style: I couldn't immediately tell who was speaking, and I have no idea what's being said. Maybe "Fire eat your heart and consume your soul! My flesh is not yours to claim. Do not try."?

Quote:
?Moist streams should not grace a face as delicate as yours.

Style, character: You'd said "moist lines" earlier, and "moist streams" now in dialogue feels unnatural.

Quote:
A clear German accent flowed from his lips, the dusty brown hair and crystal blue eyes affirming her assumption of his nationality.

Grammar: I think you've got a dangling modifier here, as neither his accent nor his lips have hair or eyes. I'd recommend "...from his lips, and his dusty brown hair and crystal blue eyes affirmed..."

Quote:
?You would not be different from those inside that hall, or you would not have come. Men can?t resist little darlings such as those harlots in there. Many from Catholic families as well?.Hmm?..I suppose you like that, do you not??

Style, character: Feels stilted.

Quote:
Her ruffled layers swayed a bit as she tensed up.

Style: This sounds a bit odd. "The ruffled layers of her dress..."?

Quote:
The German smiled; no, smirked, and laughed slightly.

Grammar: Semi-colons separate independent clauses. I think this would work better as "...smiled - no, smirked - and..."

Quote:
?Perhaps you tell the truth, though falsehoods run thick among your confidants; it is quite possible you lie to me as thickly as they would.

Style: Repetition of "thick".
Character, style: This doesn't sound like something someone would actually say.

Quote:
She shifted her position, her manner becoming feral.

Style: How was it feral?

I'd also have appreciated a bit more backstory. The characters were intriguing, and it would be great to have them built up a bit more.
Author: Mytyl

Title: Only Once

Contest Assignment Title: Free Choice

Submission Genre: Short story

Submission Being Reviewed: Hell Masked by Damiascutlass



Only once have I made the mistake of having a friend. Killing him was the worst thing I've ever had to do.

When I was presented with the job, it took all the effort I had to keep calm. There really wasn't anything surprising about it, after all. Runemaster Tebril Irkkenson was a powerful man, and powerful men tend to be the ones that capture the eyes of my customers. If I hadn't been his student, the whole thing would have been routine.

After telling the contact that I would inform "my associate" of his offer, I went to warn my master. When I was out of sight, I broke into a run.

He wasn't surprised to hear that he had enemies, only that they were too impatient to let age finish him off.

"Dani," he said to me, sighing, "you know why I've never objected to your profession."

I averted my eyes. "By the time I'm asked to kill someone, they're already dead. If I refuse, their enemies would simply find someone else." It was what I told myself almost every day.

He nodded. "And if someone is going to be paying for my death, I'd rather the money go to you."

I gasped, startled. "But you could run!"

"Where? Why?" He laughed, humorlessly, and shook his head. "To live a few more years in hiding? Dani, I am an old man."

"Please, Master Tebril," I begged, not believing his life held so little value to him.

"There are some who choose your line of work, you know. Some who enjoy it. With someone else after me, I could end up being tortured to death. Or they might send someone incompetent, someone who'd only get the job half-done and leave me to bleed to death. If I run, I'd be jumping at every shadow. It wouldn't take more than a loud noise and my heart would give out." As he listed off the possible horrors he would end up facing, I began to realize he was right, that neither of us had much choice left. "I trust you to give me a quick and painless end." He swallowed, and for a moment seemed to lose his resolve. "Just... may I have a few days to take care or some things?"

I nodded, keeping my eyes to the floor. "It would look odd, done too quickly."

"Of course. Well." He took some books out from under his desk and slid them towards me. Seeing the covers, I realized they were his personal notes. "Take these."

"You have much more worthy students," I protested.

"But none more talented. Take them."

I bowed my head, still disagreeing but wanting them too much to argue. "Thank you, Master Tebril," I said, feeling ashamed.

As I turned to leave, he stopped me. "Ah... out of curiosity. How much was I worth?" He shuffled papers on his desk, avoiding my gaze.

I tried to wet my lips, but found my mouth dry. "Fifty thousand."

"Is that... a lot?"

"The usual price is fifteen thousand," I answered.

I walked home in a daze. I didn't think I could actually do it, but what he said made sense. At this point, a swift end might be the best favor I could do for him, but that didn't keep it from feeling like a betrayal. I decided to wait it out, hoping he'd change his mind.

That night, I lay in bed, unable to sleep. I kept thinking about the Runemaster - the day we'd met, and how he'd taken pity on me, and all the years he'd looked after me. I was the daughter he never had; he was the father I never had.

A few days later, after he had eaten dinner, I was waiting for him in his study. I had left him out a bottle of wine and a glass. I rose as he entered, and went to embrace him, then let go, feeling awkward. I produced two vials and held them up before him.

"Oh. I see," was all he said, and then nodded, stiffly.

"It's not too late," I said, "I haven't told them anything." I spoke too quickly, stumbling over the words.

"Dani, I have been marked. You think they couldn't find me?"

"A hiding rune--"

He shook his head, annoyed. "You know how easily those are countered."

"They might not!"

"Danasi! We have already discussed this!"

I stood, speechless. He only used my full name when he was furious.

While I was gaping, he snatched the vials from me and began fumbling with their stoppers.

I uncorked the bottle and poured a glass for him. "Here," I said, taking back the vials. As I added them, I explained, "This one will make you feel nothing, and this... this one will stop your heart."

He took the glass, his hand trembling, and brought it to his lips. Squeezing his eyes shut, he gulped down the wine.

He stood for a moment, looking surprised. "I didn't taste a thing," he said with a nervous chuckle. "How long does it-" He sagged to the ground as his knees gave out.

I rushed to support him and helped him to bed, not believing it could really have been done. I stayed by him, holding his hand until he went to sleep.

Before he dozed off, he murmured to me, "We have no reason to fear death, no way of knowing what it's like..." His eyelids drooped, and he struggled to speak. "It could be the paradise promised by some of the temples. Who would fear that?"

I didn't know which of us he was persuading, but I nodded, and patted his hand.

I stayed there like that, kneeling by his bed, while his breathing slowed as he drifted into sleep, and then, gradually, stopped. I stayed there, too, when his death began to show itself more fully in the stiffness of the hand I still held. Sunrise was only just beginning to stain the sky when I finally left his side.

After I finished crying, I wiped my eyes and went to collect my payment.

It was several months before I worked up enough nerve to open the journals.

Aged Seeker

10,450 Points
  • Alchemy Level 10 100
  • Unfortunate Abductee 175
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
Thank you Mytyl for both the entry and the review.

You did not follow the posted format (given on the first page) for Peer Reviews but instead of asking that you re-do the entire thing, I will just ask you to edit your post and define what each comment is addressing - style, grammer, etc.

Please keep personal comments about the contest in the Headquarters thread. If you "think numbers are useless" we would be more than happy to discuss that there. I am sure we could both make valid points and explanations.

Regards...
M

Aged Seeker

10,450 Points
  • Alchemy Level 10 100
  • Unfortunate Abductee 175
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
Due to a general misunderstanding and some confusion, we have one entry that has not been reviewed.

Mytyl, you seem to have some experience so if you wouldn't mind, we would appreciate you doing the extra review. This is entirely voluntary on your part, of course, so do not hesitate to let us know if you would rather not.

Anyone may do the review if this is read before Mytyl and someone else doesn't mind the imposition.

Our thanks to anyone taking it on. I could consider bribery... hahaha.
Mahayr
Mytyl, you seem to have some experience so if you wouldn't mind, we would appreciate you doing the extra review.

Which one is it?

Aged Seeker

10,450 Points
  • Alchemy Level 10 100
  • Unfortunate Abductee 175
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
Just when I think I am highly functional... hahaha.

The poem by Misty Amethyst. You will be able to see what happened.
Mahayr
Just when I think I am highly functional... hahaha.

The poem by Misty Amethyst. You will be able to see what happened.

Erk. Poetry's not really my thing, sorry. I'm one of those "But it doesn't rhyme!" people, basically.

Aged Seeker

10,450 Points
  • Alchemy Level 10 100
  • Unfortunate Abductee 175
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
Quite alright, thank you for looking. Perhaps one of the others will do it!

Aged Seeker

10,450 Points
  • Alchemy Level 10 100
  • Unfortunate Abductee 175
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
While I still have two promises for entries, please feel free to add yours, as we were hoping for 15 rather than 10.

We will update (add to) our reviews this evening.

I will aslo be correcting a few discrepancies in the threads. Prizes are the higher ones mentioned in the CHARITY thread...

2500
1500
750
250

Thank you for your patience in this still-new venture! Getting the bugs worked out can be slow going, but hopefully it will not take much longer!

Aged Seeker

10,450 Points
  • Alchemy Level 10 100
  • Unfortunate Abductee 175
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
Judging "her tether," by Little Teacup Storm
--[ Style ] I found the style compelling. Unusual in itself, always a good thing when kept consistent, and it was. I rarely talk about spellings in poetry, taking them for independent license, and find all of it refreshing, even if I am mistaken. That is only for the author’s knowledge, and I will take it for what I see it to be. (4 - Above Average)

--[ Narrative ] This piece flows well, has its own consistency, a good meter that is easy to follow, and feels strongly definitive. (4 - Above Average)

--[ Characters ] Speaking about herself, the character is certainly well-expressed. We all struggle with our own perceptions about our mothers, and this one was clear enough to me. And something I can relate to personally. (4 - Above Average)

--[ Grammar & Punctuation ] Poetry is difficult to judge in this area. I found the usage, as I said, refreshing. (4 - Above Average)

--[ Plot | Originality ] I read this over several times and found it to be gripping, well-stated, and while the theme – speaking about one’s mother – may be common, the way it was done was definitely original. (4 - Above Average)

--[ Overall ] I think the above speaks my feelings about the poem. I was touched, could relate to the theme and the words used, and found it an enjoyable read. (4 – Above Average)

Aged Seeker

10,450 Points
  • Alchemy Level 10 100
  • Unfortunate Abductee 175
  • Risky Lifestyle 100

Aged Seeker

10,450 Points
  • Alchemy Level 10 100
  • Unfortunate Abductee 175
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
Judging "Tears of Heartbreak," by Misty Amethyst
--[ Style ]

--[ Narrative ]

--[ Characters ]

--[ Grammar & Punctuation ]

--[ Plot | Originality ]

--[ Overall ] Unfortunately, this piece just does not fit in with the rest of the entries. There is really no fair way to review it in the light of the competition. It was too short, for one thing – only 43 words. While not being exactly disqualified on its face, there is really no need for me to say more than this. (In light of this contest 1 - Poor)

Aged Seeker

10,450 Points
  • Alchemy Level 10 100
  • Unfortunate Abductee 175
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
Judging "Hell Masked," by Damiascutlass
--[ Style ] I found the general style to be inconsistent, sometimes using the standard of today, sometimes shifting to an older world one. Word usage was often dubious and sometimes inappropriate. There were repetitions that could have been avoided. (1 - Poor)

--[ Narrative ] Again, there seemed to be a shift between reality and what is commonly seen in role play. It would have been better to choose one or the other. The story did move forward in a logical manner and there was some depth of feeling. Some of the dialogue felt contrived, although mistakes in grammar could be chalked up to an imperfection in the character and not the writer. (2 - Fair)

--[ Characters ] The characters as a group were not convincing. There was too much change in opinion, mood, and behaviour. Again, this sounded more like role play than story telling. There were tidbits of honesty, and I think if the piece was re-thought from one (consistent) angle it would take on a more solid feeling altogether. (2 - Fair)

--[ Grammar & Punctuation ] Some sentence structures were well thought out, others could have been improved. Punctuation needs a more thorough going over. Grammatical mistakes in the dialogue were irritating, but then so were some of the characters, and understandably so. (3 - Average)

--[ Plot | Originality ] While some of the subject matter was intended to be shocking or harsh, I found no originality in this story. There were a few redeeming features that could be explored, broadened, and expounded upon. A good idea that was just too predictable and already over done. Angsty-tough-but-looking-for-something damsel-in-distress syndrome. (2 - Fair)

--[ Overall ] I was sorry to give such a harsh-sounding review to a writer who has some obvious experience with role play and is probably quite decent at it. Unfortunately, role play style does not work well as a short story piece. Such a storyline must be completely re-worked to fit the medium. Please let me know if you want specifics and plan to do a re-write. (2 - Fair)

Quick Reply

Submit
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum