Author and title: Damiascutlass - Hell Masked
Style: 3
-- Comments: see below.
Narrative: 4
-- Comments: see below.
Characters: 2
-- Comments: see below.
Grammar, etc: 4
-- Comments: see below.
Plot/originality: 4
-- Comments: see below.
Overall: 4
-- Comments: Don't let my nit-picking that follows fool you; I liked this story and enjoyed reading it. I could tell what was coming and dread the ending while still hoping for it to turn out better, without it feeling too predictable (narrative, plot/originality). My main problems with it were some awkward sentence constructions (style) and stilted dialogue (style, characters?). Keep in mind that these are all just my opinion. Since it's your story, your opinion is the one that counts.
And now, since I think numbers are useless:
Quote:
If through Grace and God she could survive through the night, perhaps she would be devout to God as she was meant to be.
Style: "Grace and God" sounds odd - did you maybe mean "the grace of God"? Or it could just be an expression I'm unfamiliar with.
Style: The "God [...] God" sounds a bit repetitive.
Character: Why was she meant to be devout?
Grammar, style: I'm guessing the question marks are quotes that didn't show up; if they are, they aren't needed. Either it's a party or it isn't - if it isn't, tell us what it is.
Quote:
it was hoped by her to be true
Style: Normally I don't mind passive constructions, but this feels weak and awkward. Maybe something like "at least she hoped"?
Grammar: "fetishist"?
Quote:
the chandeliers graced only with the light of wax candles
Style: Sounds a bit awkward, like the chandeliers are the subject of the illumination.
Quote:
The men all wore old-fashioned suits, all seeming to suit the Victorian Age of England, the suits all dark and worn.
Style: Repetition of "all" and "suit".
Quote:
But, of course Fate wound its threads in a less desirable manner.
Style: The beginnings and ends of sentences are their strongest points - starting with a conjunction weakens them. I suggest "Fate, however, wound..." although some people dislike "however".
Quote:
The spiraling staircase wound up to the second floor, though candlelight was insufficient to find one?s way up it.
Style: "up it" is unnecessary and weakens the sentence.
Quote:
her ankles crossed on the marble ground, moist lines upon her face, slightly blackened by the old-fashioned make-up
Style, grammar: I'd recommend splitting these descriptive phrases up into separate sentences; they may also be dangling.
Quote:
whom had divorced her mother
Grammar: "who". Test: "He had divorced her mother," or "Him had divorced her mother."
Quote:
he could also be harsh and strange
Character, style: How is he harsh, and how is he strange?
Quote:
A soft hand trailed on her semi-bared shoulder
Narrative: I didn't immediately pick up that this was someone else's hand.
Quote:
Staring at the person who had smoothed their hand over her skin, played with her curl, her eyes hardened.
Grammar: "Their" is plural, so "his" might be better.
Quote:
?Fire eat your heart, and consume your soul, yet my flesh is not yours to claim. Do not dare try it.?
Style: I couldn't immediately tell who was speaking, and I have no idea what's being said. Maybe "Fire eat your heart and consume your soul! My flesh is not yours to claim. Do not try."?
Quote:
?Moist streams should not grace a face as delicate as yours.
Style, character: You'd said "moist lines" earlier, and "moist streams" now in dialogue feels unnatural.
Quote:
A clear German accent flowed from his lips, the dusty brown hair and crystal blue eyes affirming her assumption of his nationality.
Grammar: I think you've got a dangling modifier here, as neither his accent nor his lips have hair or eyes. I'd recommend "...from his lips, and his dusty brown hair and crystal blue eyes affirmed..."
Quote:
?You would not be different from those inside that hall, or you would not have come. Men can?t resist little darlings such as those harlots in there. Many from Catholic families as well?.Hmm?..I suppose you like that, do you not??
Style, character: Feels stilted.
Quote:
Her ruffled layers swayed a bit as she tensed up.
Style: This sounds a bit odd. "The ruffled layers of her dress..."?
Quote:
The German smiled; no, smirked, and laughed slightly.
Grammar: Semi-colons separate independent clauses. I think this would work better as "...smiled - no, smirked - and..."
Quote:
?Perhaps you tell the truth, though falsehoods run thick among your confidants; it is quite possible you lie to me as thickly as they would.
Style: Repetition of "thick".
Character, style: This doesn't sound like something someone would actually say.
Quote:
She shifted her position, her manner becoming feral.
Style: How was it feral?
I'd also have appreciated a bit more backstory. The characters were intriguing, and it would be great to have them built up a bit more.