Welcome to Gaia! ::

Captain's Guild 2.0

Back to Guilds

Accepting Guild and Clan captains and crew alike! 

Tags: captain's, guild, network, clans, developers 

Reply GGN Support
Suggestions for the Improvement of The Captains Guild Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Syntria
Crew

PostPosted: Thu Oct 23, 2008 4:04 pm


Yep, we're still a fledgling Guild but with our eyes set on becoming the number one Captain and Crew's Resource, we have to set our standards high.

So, suggestions are welcomed. Keep in mind this Guild's focus, and those suggestions should be made in order to maximize that focus.
PostPosted: Thu Oct 23, 2008 4:05 pm


I suggest that polls should not be permitted in the main forum that do not directly relate to the thread in some fashion.

No Polls Just for Gold or Poll Whoring. They should be 'how would you rate my guild' or 'what do you think about Gaia's Current Guild System?'. Real Polls Only.

But that's just an suggestion, obviously.

Syntria
Crew


lily564a
Crew

PostPosted: Fri Oct 24, 2008 6:54 am


I suggest this

User Image
PostPosted: Fri Oct 24, 2008 7:39 am


Hey. I think that looks pretty nice.

Syntria
Crew


lily564a
Crew

PostPosted: Fri Oct 24, 2008 7:55 am


Thanks
PostPosted: Fri Oct 24, 2008 8:17 am


Though I do have to say, I'm hearing a call out from various individuals involved in the different Guilds for a unification rather than having three branches of it. I can't help but feel supportive of this, but I'm waiting to see if there's a neat way to do it without it all turning into a 'power struggle'. I hope this isn't seen as alienating my loyalties to this Guild. I'm loyal to the idea of a unified rebirth of the Captain's Guild. Not triplets. XD

Syntria
Crew


lily564a
Crew

PostPosted: Fri Oct 24, 2008 8:40 am


I think we'd do better remaining separate but work together, all the new captain guilds have unique ideas on how it should be done, potentially this could attract and sustain more captains than a single guild.

We should be like the Confederated States of America, together but individual
PostPosted: Fri Oct 24, 2008 11:12 am


I think individually it'd be beneficial to those in control of the guilds, but as a whole for the Gaia community...I'm not sure.

Like, we accept Crew Members despite the name being 'The Captain's Guild'. That alone sort of takes away from the meaning of the name to me, not that I don't love crew members. It just isn't representational of the title at all.

I don't know, I just wonder if we're trying to make the best Captain's guild for gaian's or riding the credibility of the name to get a 'cool' Guild.

lol, sorry. I'm in too many diplomatic and sociology classes right now. (literally, in one right now)

Like, another thing. We've got nothing to discuss the rumors up about zomg being involved with the Guilds, or th supposed mass-guild updates that are coming right after zomg. All we really have is what the Old Guild had. Do we have anyone who has the connections to know about these things as soon as they become known?

lol, sorry again. I'm just venting and getting all my confused little concerns out.

Syntria
Crew


Syntria
Crew

PostPosted: Sun Oct 26, 2008 10:55 pm


Hey? I bet there's Petitions out there aimed at certain features/updates to be done to the Guilds? If so, we should get a list of these petitions for users to sign if they choose too!

*idea*
PostPosted: Mon Oct 27, 2008 1:37 pm


That sounds like a great idea, but I doubt it's a practical undertaking for us to find and list all the petitions relating to guilds; instead maybe we try to spread the word that we're compiling a list and have them come to us. The problem with that is we'll need to stay active in the petition community to keep a current list.

On the subject of lists I think we should keep a list of hazardous people, scammers, hackers, and the lot

lily564a
Crew


WindowOpener
Captain

PostPosted: Mon Oct 27, 2008 3:57 pm


Certainly there are some larger petitions that we could find and link to in this guild - we don't need a comprehensive list, but the more the better. ^^ We could link them in the Suggestions List sticky.

Since pirula said she'll be keeping an eye on that, it would be great for us to keep that sticky in mind whenever we have ideas about guilds. The one in the CG often seemed to go for many months without edits.

I don't think a list of scammers, hackers, etc. would be helpful. sweatdrop If you come across one, report him/her and move on. Those lists are always outdated because those accounts are usually banned (or otherwise dealt with by the mods). So threats don't usually come from the same account twice, and of course there's no other way to predict where they'll come from in the future, so the lists don't help. ^^;
PostPosted: Mon Oct 27, 2008 5:34 pm


Maybe the rules could be tweeked in the main forum? Or we could even have a full discussion about the guild layout. ^^ Because the main forum, 'GGN Support,' is currently borrowing all the characteristics of the CG's main forum, which means it is targeted at technical help for using guilds. I don't know exactly the direction Radimir wants to take this in, but so far those who have been invited are generally pretty well-rounded with knowledge of how guilds work. ninja heart

WindowOpener
Captain


xX_Radimir_Xx
Crew

PostPosted: Mon Oct 27, 2008 6:18 pm


lily564a
I suggest this

User Image


The mod panel is being glitchy again, but I'll use that as the new banner as soon it start functioning again (:

@MistressPaco

That poll idea seems a bit harsh, no? I don't really know about that. Honestly, even though I run a poll guild, I've never really liked polls all that much because they confuse me when I'm searching for threads sometimes.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Yep. All of our ideas and ways are somewhat different. I only started this version because I prefer seeing all the guild-information in a guild rather than in the forums. I'm more comfortable that way. And the mods said they'd only move some of the information from the CG to the forums and that doesn't include any of the guides, except for the two that were stickied maybe.

I have nothing against the other versions, except that I don't exactly side with how they've been made. It might not hurt to post links to them though to let others know about them.

Once this guild is well established, I think it would definitely be beneficial to affiliate with the GGN Moderator's Guild and they've been talking about that themselves.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

That's been bugging me a bit too. I've been thinking that again, once this guild is really established, we should change our title to something else. I'm going so far as too accept people that used to be Captains, VCs, or crew members too just because they might have their own words to pitch in, even though they won't really be able to prove they were once one of those things.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I've signed a few of those petitions! Maybe we could integrate them into the Guild Suggestion- wait never mind, I just read ahead in the Topic Review box and Window already said it (idea stealer xp ). There are some petitions from 04 I think.

I sent Pirula a PM and asked her to review the sticky and let me know which ideas can't be implemented so I can updated it. I took a look at it and I was thinking maybe it'd be better to just almost completely restart it?

Yeah, that might be something you could do in the Captain's Chat forum as a regular list maybe, as long as you can prove they hacked or scammed, etc. Otherwise, I don't really see what it would have to do with this guild. It may not be bad for the Market forum though because I keep a list in my shop of people that have scammed me.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I've never really understood "GGN support" to be honest sweatdrop Want to explain your vision of the main forum a bit more Window? XD
PostPosted: Mon Oct 27, 2008 6:28 pm


Yes, the communication in the Captains' Guild was never very crisp on what each of the forums was designed for - that was my fault. :XP:

GGN Support basically meant - anything about the GGN. That's the Gaia Guild Network, as distinct from any individual guilds in it. So any topics that were about the GGN, or guilds, without being about a guild, were generally good.

This included things like asking how something worked - 'GGN functionality,' you could call it. So most help threads (as distinct from 'advice' threads, which would focus on a guild) would go there.

Glitches and feature suggestions also stayed in GGN Support because they are about the whole GGN.

The word discussion was also slipped into the rules & guidelines for GGN Support. whee So you could create discussion threads about the whole GGN, too. There was potentially some ambiguity here - technically it would be possible to have a discussion about captaining in a general sense, without relating it to any specific guild, even though the Guild Discussion forum was intended for that. I'm a bit disappointed in retrospect that there was never enough interest in discussion at all to result in a need for clearer rules. XP

So to propose a direction for this forum, surprise surprise, I'd suggest shifting the emphasis more for discussion (e.g. 'GGN Discussion') as technical help isn't needed generally amongst the members here (so far, anyway - but if you anticipate growing to a point where it would be helpful, then that's something to consider). It could also be pooled with discussion of any kind - related to the whole GGN, or a guild. No specific reason why these should be split, unless there's so much of it that splitting them actually helps people.

WindowOpener
Captain


lily564a
Crew

PostPosted: Mon Oct 27, 2008 6:36 pm


As to who should be allowed in, I think we should figure a way to allow people who are seriously considering buying a guild to join, so they can benefit from our experience in their purchase and initial planning; the best way would be to wait for the ability to make public subforums in a private/hidden guild, but as Pirula said it could be a long time before the GGN backbone is health enough to accept major alterations like that. The other solution would be to buy/rent out a sister guild that's open to the public, but hell if I know enough other stuff we could put in there to justify it. That gives me an idea for a suggestion...
Reply
GGN Support

Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum