Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply Gundam
Wing Analysis Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Shishio Guy

PostPosted: Fri Dec 30, 2005 12:25 pm


In all seriousness, CE Machines aren't really measured in ability, rather than how much the fanboys/fangirls love'em. Duel only beat Forbidden only because Fukuda favored Yzak's VA. Strike competing against the newer ZAFT models was stupid. It was still outclassed like hell, just because Fukuda wanted to show some stupidly obvious gap between SF and Strike. Freedom only beat Saviour and Destroy only because a good number of viewers are Kira fangirls/fanboys and we all know that CE isn't going for an orignal plot, but merely blowjobbing to the fanboys/fangirls. And Wing is more realistic than you think. Just because you wanna be an asshat and refute everything like a babbling basher doesn't change that.

I mean, considering that the damned machines are taking on... Oh, about more than 100x their numbers, I'd think that they'd be more godly than they are already. But sadly, they even have their own limitations. Wing only has 3 shots of the full-power Buster Rifle, and in all seriousness, that's not enough. After that, it only has a beam saber and machinecannons. Machinecannons can only shoot for so long, and Doberguns do have an effect on Gundanium Armor, just not immediately visible. If there are enough well placed Leos, they could easily overwhelm the Wing via prevention of movement and interception during advancement to melee combat. Heavyarms. For a unit with only solid weaponry, this is tough. I mean, sure it has a lot of guns, but once its all gone, you only have a ******** knife. Wow. And its not even that long. Force the sucker to expend his ammo against your numbers, then pound him with more numbers from long range. Its a heavy unit, so it'll be easier to prevent melee combat. Deathscythe. The unit has some nice cloaking, but it has no really good ranged weapons. The cloaking isn't exactly perfect either. The others have a lot of other flaws I'm too lazy to bring up, but the machines only coincidencially make a good fighting team when put together.

In all seriousness, I find more of the CE suits to be less realistic. I mean, Freedom. That machine has guns and an aimbot. Wow. And don't even give me the "advanced targetting computer" bullshit. Its a ******** aimbot. I mean, all MS have a ******** targetting computer. The only way you could make it "advanced" is by making it autolock like an aimbot. And amazingly, this "advanced targetting computer" allows its accuracy to be miraculously higher than an MS not using it. Wow. Now is that an aimbot or what? Strike Freedom's "Super DRAGOONs" are just Incoms on crack or some sort of system that makes you a wannabe newtype. Gee... Isn't that brilliant? Don't go "Zero System = Hax" or whatever, because the damned thing at least puts mental strain on the pilot. I mean, with tons of info and suggestions being put into the brain, you could just as easily die from it as you could kill with it. And an "emergency shutdown" button. Just more retcon just to save the dude all the fanboys and fangirls swoon over. The TSA Ships come through with little to no damage, and that's attributable to fanboy/fangirl love. I mean, a good number of their fleet was wiped out, yet they still make some sort of comeback against a ******** ARMY. Wing's situation was at least managable because it was a 3-way free for all. And I-J piercing Messiah's barrier? Total bullshit. There is a good size difference. I would've expected him to have a little more trouble than what actually happened. I mean, firing a beam rifle at an asteroid's not going to do much. Why should a beam shield hitting one that's enough to cover a giant space fortress be any different?

I liked Wing because at least it didn't go running around blowjobbing to all the ******** fanboys/fangirls.
PostPosted: Fri Dec 30, 2005 5:40 pm


Cute. Just as I thought, you could not leave it as it was, even after making that copout. Not suprising, but I'd think you'd at least be able to avoid it when I make it excruciatingly clear my entire post is just bait. And despite your claims that you don't care, you've come back once more to respond despite your having already copped out. Are you going to further this contradiction...?
NewtypeS3
Poor Shani... what made you so bitchy and incapable of comprehending the idea of an opinion, much less capable of accepting the opinions of others?

I'm sorry, but exactly how is opinion involved in the realism of these shows? While you may assume opinion is my motivation all you want, when my motivation is instead your obvious provocation. And this is exactly the kind of talking-down-to bullshit that got you in this mess in the first place. You should really keep that s**t in check. wink
And don't call me hypocritical for talking down to you, because my doing so is fully justified since I'm not the one running away...and because I've clearly crushed you in pretty much all aspects, to the point where you run away.
NewtypeS3
See, you actually started this by telling me to respond to the points of contention you had with Wing. I responded. Things snowballed from there.

No, you started this with your childish little provocation. While it is indeed in your best interest to try and save face at this point, where you look like such a coward in the way you're running from something you started, it will not work that way. But of course...if you don't care, as you claim...why would you try so hard to deny the truth?
NewtypeS3
Oh, and Shani? Quit the crap with the 'Wing Fans don't reason' train of thought. We obviously do reason... Please, just stop.
And NONE of Gundam is realistic, if you really wanna get into it.
And Lady Une's not the only 'Winger' who can maintain intelligent conversations... I know of a few others... twisted

As I said, childish and inflammatory. You call my case "crap", you use a disrespectful tone overall, and you throw in some childish quasi-threat at the end. If you can spout s**t like that and expect no response, no conflict of any kind to come from it...I don't know, that's just pretty ******** up. You can try and fall back on any technicalities you want, saying "but you put up the challenge, lol", but that won't change the fact that it never would've taken place without your provocation. Your inflammatory post was the cause to my challenge's effect.
NewtypeS3
However, that doesn't mean I have to continue, Shani.

Stray Bullet Shani
Feel free to run away with your tail between your legs, now.

An excerpt from my previous post.
NewtypeS3
Stereotypical "LOLINTERNET" bullshit.

Alright, and? Whether or not you care is irrelevant at this point, all that matters is that you're running away from something you essentially started with your foolish provocation. If you're so confident, then prove it by being man enough to own up to it; even simply leaving and not responding is better than all this denial crap.
NewtypeS3
So, please, continue to insult Wing and all who support it. With you in charge, I now see why this is pratically a dead board.

"And all who support it"?
Now you assume that I treat all wingers as I treat the stupid ones?
And I'd also like to reiterate, that my wing bashing and my running this forum do not go hand in hand. My having not banned you for being a winger, and my not deleting wing topics is proof enough of that. I can say, honestly, that I have never used my powers as the captain of this guild for anti-wing purposes. You, as a person new to this forum, have no right to judge the ability of my moderators, myself, or anyone else involved in the running of this forum, not when you have yet to witness any administrative or moderator action from either myself or my staff.

Alright, now onto Guy.

Stray Bullet Shani


Stray Bullet Shani

PostPosted: Fri Dec 30, 2005 5:58 pm


Shishio Guy
In all seriousness, CE Machines aren't really measured in ability, rather than how much the fanboys/fangirls love'em. Duel only beat Forbidden only because Fukuda favored Yzak's VA. Strike competing against the newer ZAFT models was stupid. It was still outclassed like hell, just because Fukuda wanted to show some stupidly obvious gap between SF and Strike. Freedom only beat Saviour and Destroy only because a good number of viewers are Kira fangirls/fanboys and we all know that CE isn't going for an orignal plot, but merely blowjobbing to the fanboys/fangirls.

I don't see how that would invalidate my invalidation of his statement. Wait, it doesn't. K. You're just bitching and moaning about SEED to try and create some kind of tangential argument to prolong the conflict meaninglessly. His original point on SEED in the first place was irrelevant on its own, and without the motivation I once had to defend SEED, I don't see any point in putting forth the effort to refute your statements...since they're just spinoffs of an irrelevant point anyways.
Shishio Guy
And Wing is more realistic than you think. Just because you wanna be an asshat and refute everything like a babbling basher doesn't change that.

I refute things because they are untrue. As you can see, where I had made the mistake in remembrance of the magunacs survival, I freely admit what is wrong or right.
Shishio Guy
b***h b***h b***h, moan moan moan.

K.
Shishio Guy
I liked Wing because at least it didn't go running around blowjobbing to all the ******** fanboys/fangirls.

....
Funniest. s**t. ******** hell, I can't stop laughing.
PostPosted: Thu Jan 12, 2006 4:32 pm


can anyone tell me what's so great with Epyon?
or all three editions of Tallgeese?

Vivio1412


NewtypeS3

PostPosted: Thu Jan 12, 2006 6:16 pm


Barsona
can anyone tell me what's so great with Epyon?


Well, Epyon was made by Treize in secret - and it contains a slightly altered version of the ZERO System. This one's known as the EPYON System, and seems to have some of Treize's own touches within it - stuff that made Heero go bonkers, but not Zechs.

Epyon is also the only suit with the beam saber connected directly to the reactor, whereas all other beam sabers on mobile suits have to have their power routed through the arms and hand plugs - each of which have serious power limitations.
With the power flowing directly from the source, the beam saber of Epyon's is essentially larger and supposrdly stronger as well.

Epyon also has the second example of a heated melee weapon in the Wing Universe - possibly being built off the Sandrock data used to rebuild Sandrock that Oz had. This, of course, is the head whip (or rod, depending on translation and sites used).

In addition, Epyon has a Mobile Armour mode, which always helps.

Fun note: Epyon was designed alongside a sister unit: The Aquarius, which was another melee-only suit: designed with 2 heat rods and some anti-Mobile Doll scramblers built into the unit to destory the command systems within the MD themselves.
Sadly, this one was never built.

Barsona
or all three editions of Tallgeese?


The Tallgeeses (Tallgooses?) are a different story.

Tallgeese I
was built by Howard, the old man who aids the Gundam Pilots in Wing. The Tallgeese was one of the first attempts to make a suit worth Mass-Producing for Oz - but was not only too expensive to MP, but was also rather large.

The Tallgeese Zechs used was then put into storage, unfinished. There are rumored to be 3 others, one of which actually made it to Wufei's home colony and was piloted by his wife before she died.

In any case, the Tallgeese has the vernier boosters notorious for breaking ribs and actually gave Zechs a minor heart attack when he first piloted the machine - same with the test pilot named Otto as well.

Tallgeese is basically built for plain 1-on-1 combat, it seems: The Dobergun often runs out of ammo during combat, and the only other weapons on Tallgeese are the beam sabers.

Also of note is that, while it has the armour a little better than a Leo, the Tallgeese is the only mecha to stand up to the Gundams repeatedly and survive.

Tallgeese I was obliterated, but (like I said), there were others. Another Tallgeese / Prototype Leo was taken out of storage and became Treize's Tallgeese II.

The Tallgeese II has almost no changes from the old Tallgeese I, though footage of Wing (as well as SRW games) suggest that the Tallgeese II actually had a beam rifle in place of the Dobergun.

Aside from the new paintjob and new frill on the helmet, though, no other changes were noted.

Tallgeese III is actually the suit that Treize wanted to use in the end of Wing, but was not completed on time - forcing him to use the hastily repainted Tallgeese II. It's also rumored that Tallgeese III is the final Proto Leo, showing that all 4 suits were pretty much in use at some time or another.

Tallgeese III has several changes over the previous 2 suits. For one, it seems that the Tallgeese III can actually reach escape velocities (with or without boosters isn't confirmed, though the Tallgeese I did it with boosters), which it used to reach MO III to try and stop the Barton Foundation invasion.

The Tallgeese III also tossed away the idea of the Dobergun, replacing it with a 'Megacannon,' containing two modes. The first is normal file, but the second puts it on par with the Twin Buster Rifle - however the entire suit is drained of much of it's power when the Mega Cannon's ultimate mode is used.

Tallgeese III also has the Head Rod that Epyon had, with a similar shield design as well.

And, of course, the Tallgeese III had an increase in speed, armour and agility.

The important thing to note, though, is that the Tallgeese is the first suit to go toe-to-toe with the Gundams - when it's a 20-year-old design, further suggesting that the Leo would have done better had they focused on speed and not mass-production.
PostPosted: Sun Jan 15, 2006 8:08 am


About Wing being fan service:

Sure, the guys are hot and that's fanservice but Wing isn't entirely that. First of all, everyone who watched SEED will notice the sex and bath scenes, nudity and jiggly boobs. Wing, on the otherhand, isn't that pervy and is remarkably chaste. Also, Flay, who was hated, got killed off while Relena, who a lot of fangirls wish dead, lives on. Mu was brought back to life and the Wing equivalent of that is Zechs back from the dead. Also, isn't Lacus the epitome of fanservice? A cute popstar who leads a battlefleet... If that ain't fanservice, I don't know what is...

Edit: Shani, I really appreciate the fact that you're lenient with Wingers. Admittedly, a ton of them are stupid but some can be pretty smart. NewtypeS3 and I don't wish to undermine your authority in anyway. Like you, we're just trying to state our opinion. We apologize if we are over-zealous at times. I just want to post, stick with the rules, discuss Gundam and have fun. Please bring it to my attention if we're breaking rules or going against your authority.

Colonel Lady Une


Vivio1412

PostPosted: Sun Jan 15, 2006 2:46 pm


Kira has an aimbot?
lol, what a hax
Reply
Gundam

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum