Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply Roleplays or OOC s**t
The RP Sample Grading Thread Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Is this a good idea?
  Yes
  No
  pole whoer
View Results

fallenseeker

PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 8:46 am


Alright, I'm sure plenty of you have wondered at some point, "Is this any good?" I know I have, and that wondering was what gave birth to this: The RP Sample Grading Thread. Tons of members of the Herd are great at RP (I don't count myself in that number), so why not ask them for a grade or some advice?

If you want something graded, post it. Those who feel qualified enough to grade, tell us what you think of it. I only ask that anyone who plans to grade submit one of their own samples first, just to make things fair. When you post something, include whether or not you want a numerical grade. If you are just looking for feedback without a numerical grade, please indicate that this is the case.

To clarify, people are to grade the quality of writing, not the content. To this end, use a rating out of 10, and include a qualifier. Posts are either: n00b, sub-lit, semi-lit, lit, advanced lit. (Unless a better scale exists.)


Now, if you'll all give me a moment to reserve some posts, I'll set up what will eventually become the organization system for the RP samples, set up in alphabetical order.
PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 8:47 am


Names A-E

~Dameon Grey~

Sample 1:

~Dameon Grey~
The night had drawn on longer than he'd hoped, Marcus was indeed a handful. He was long winded, easily distracted, almost too energetic for Mahi. Nonetheless he gave him what he'd promised, and now the cold coffee in the small glued together mug in his hands swirled tiny stowaway coffee grains in the center while he looked out over the train tracks below.

Marcus walked up behind him and rubbed his shoulder gently, kissing the back of his neck. "Ya want some muffins.... muffin?" He laughed softly.

"That... was bad..." Mahi turned around and gave him a poke, trying not to laugh at the horrible joke. It was too early for cheesy jokes. He gave him a n** on his jaw and headed inside, the loose blanket slipping off his shoulders and down over his bare body while he searched for an over sized shirt of his tutor's he could wear.

"Here...." Marcus handed him instead an over sized wool sweater. The sleeves too long, the bottom hanging almost to his knees. Marcus was an enormous man, Mahi liked his shirts, they were like giant nightgowns on him and he never had to worry about revealing too much if he bent over. "Eat..." Marcus commanded with a grin and gave Mahi a plate of German pancakes. His weakness, this man could make some really good German pancakes.

"What happened to the muffins?" He asked.

"You can have one of those too, or two even."

"No i like these more..." He smirked and doused his with powdered sugar and lemon and butter then cut a giant chunk off stuffing it in his mouth. "Mmmm... so what do we have today?" He asked with his mouth full. Marcus smirked and held up a white piece of paper in front of Mahi, he'd seen this before, the *philosopher's curse. Mahi smirked and looked up at Marcus then to the paper again and nodded. "Ok..." He said and sat back in his chair taking another bite.


Ratings

8/10
MorteKitten
Well, I love that it's descriptive, almost made me feel like I was right there, watching the scene unfolding before me. The flow of the words and conversation were set at a good pace. The part didn't seem like you were trying to rush through it. The people and objects weren't too over detailed, which is good. The writing style seemed relaxed and not too structured. You also make the characters seem very comfortable with each other and not as if they are forced together.
I'd rate it an eight out of ten.


7/10
fallenseeker
Dameon, you're next. This sample is difficult for me to grade for a few reasons. There are a few extremely nit-picky grammar errors that for some reason jumped out and bit me in the a**, which sorta hurts you. Also, the setting is extremely undefined, but that could just be a product of what RP tends to be like; you might have just stated the setting in the last post and whatever you would be writing would be redundant. It causes a bit of difficulty. Still, I felt like you said a good amount about these characters in just a few short lines, and you made it very interesting to read. Overall, I'll give it a 7, but improved grammar would bring it up.

fallenseeker


fallenseeker

PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 8:48 am


Names F-K

fallenseeker
Sample:
Quote:
Tath woke up, gradually. He lay in his bed for a moment, and then pulled the blanket from his eyes, groaning a bit as the light hit his eyes through the window. “Damn…It’s still day, isn’t it.” He said, looking over at his shadow.

“Well, I’m here to answer you; what do you think, Tath?”

He pulled the blanket off the rest of his body, revealing his whole body, then rolling off the bed. “Damn…I hate waking up in the day…” What kind of vampire didn't?

His shadow laughed at him. “I don’t mind at all, it’s the only time I even get to exist.”

Tath glared at the dark shape on the floor. His shadow had a way of saying exactly what he needed to hear to get annoyed. He paced around the room, thinking about what to do for the day. “I don’t even have a feeding to look forward to tonight; I have to skip town, while they still think that buffoon is the problem.” He walked over to the trunk in the corner of the room and got himself dressed, pulling on his leather armor vest.

Shadow Tath laughed again. “Yeah, you’ve worked out a clever system over all the years,” he said as he matched his master’s every move. “Come to town, rob everyone blind, and feed when you need to. Then, when everyone suspects you, you turn the most influential man in town and desert him. The peasants catch him on his first or second attempt to feed; they see the problem is solved. That’s when you take everything you can and skip town.”

Tath only chuckled as he threw his dark robe on over the armor. “It’s been working so far; and it’s gonna work again tonight. Until then, we’ll just have to wait. Go grab the chess set. Oh, that’s right.” He got up, laughing at his shadow, pulling out the chess set and walking over to the table.

Ratings:

Ffaux Pas- Come read his archive
PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 8:52 am


Names L-R

MorteKitten


Sample 1

MorteKitten
The girl watched the guy in the mask add the 20 dollar bill to his pile of money. She noticed that he barely even noticed the boy who gave him the twenty dollars. She hoped he'd at least share a hamburger with him.

"You don't have all day?" The girl murmured under her breath. 'Ungrateful customers,' She thought to herself. She grabbed up the money and returned behind the counter. She punched in the cost of the burgers and then the amount of money she'd been given. The register made a ping, but wouldn't open. She sighed and balled up her fist and hit the register. It clanked and then opened. One day she'd have to buy a new one. She inserted the money and closed the drawer. The register made a few clanking and crunching sounds, then spat out a slip of paper that detailed the man's purchases. She slid the paper into her pocket to give to him later.

She went into the kitchen and saw that the grill had a slow steam rising off of it. If she didn't put something on it soon, the whole place would be filled with smoke. She quickly opened the refrigerator and pulled out two trays full of hand-pressed patties. They were pretty large and thick because once they cooked, they'd shrink in size and she wanted the burgers to actually be seen, after she finished cooking them. She took a towel that she covered in a thin coat of cooking oil and wiped it over the grill. It sizzled and she knew it was ready. She plopped each patty down, counting to twenty. Dang! She'd have to make more patties. Hopefully, there was some thawed ground meat in the fridge she could use.

She walked back to the fridge and saw that there was a large bowl of ground meat, but it probably wouldn't be enough to equal 80 patties. Maybe twenty more patties. Great, she'd be stuck here all night cooking burgers for some strange guy in a mask. She had a feeling she should have charged him more money. Well, maybe she'd get a nice tip.

She opened the freezer and pulled out two more frozen packs of ground meat. They would have to thaw. She couldn't just leave them in the fridge, it'd take hours for them to thaw out. She placed them in the huge sink that was located near the grill. She turned on some warm water. She went back to the freezer and took out two more packs of ground meat. That should be enough to make 60 burgers. She let the warm water run over them, then stopped the sink, so the water would stay in place and help the meat to thaw out.

She went back to check her burgers. She used her spatula to lift up a patty, it was just starting to brown. That reminded her. She didn't ask him how he wanted his burgers. If she was lucky, he'd want them rare.

She went back out into the diner, noting that the man in the top hat hadn't moved. Well, maybe he was having a boring night. She couldn't blame him. The town they were in didn't offer much in the way of entertainment. She'd spent many a night lost in a book or an interesting show because there wasn't anything else to do.

She walked up to the masked man. "I'm sorry. How did you want your burgers? Rare, medium, or well done ... sir?"


Ratings

7.5/10
~Dameon Grey~
Ok then, where to start. I liked it ^w^, i'd say maybe... on a scale of one to ten icon_sweatdrop.gif um... a seven?.... maybe an eight? ._. Because it is a good piece, the only thing that bugged me was the use of the same word more than once in a sentence, and repetitive beginnings to sentences one right after the other. You had some "she did this. she saw that.... she thinks" it was just kind of... mechanical i guess i'll say. But i did like how we don't know her, we at least get to see her character's personality, how she operates under pressure >w< and she seems to know her way around the kitchen so it's not like someone new to roleplaying where you throw them in and you yourself don't know how to have her react... If that makes sense at all ._.

fallenseeker


fallenseeker

PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 8:54 am


Names S-Z

Vanadia Gold

Sample 1
Vanadia Gold
The blood was vibrant that night, trickling down her face and mingling with the ink of her hair. As her eyes closed and opened she watched him leave her behind. The terror on his face, his beloved face, as he ran away from the broken body at the bottom of the stairs would forever be etched into the blank slate of her mind.

"...love you..." Her cooling lips mouthed the words to the back of her young lover. His white face contrasted with his deep red hair, and as he ran away, the darkness began to creep up through her vision.

"...need yo-..." That was when her last breath escaped her lips, and as he looked back on her, all he would remember for the rest of his few days were the vibrance of her blood eyes. Just as scarlet as the fluid pooling about her navy dress, the tips of her raven hair turned sticky and matted with it. Her life was pouring out of her body, and her body froze as it was; one hand forever reached out to the one that left her behind.

They had gone to the hottest theme park in the whole country that night. She had been so happy, riding all of the rides, and eating cotton candy until she was sick. She bounced along in her dress, dragging her beloved by the hand to the scariest place Zero Parade had to offer. In her enthusiasm, she supposed she hadn't seen how dim his eyes were, or how little attention he really gave her. But in the Haunted House, with it's spray painted ghouls and fake skeletons, he pulled her to the side. In a side room, where only employees were supposed to go, he took her face in his hands. The gleaming machinary that controlled the mechanics of the house stood in the background as the moonlight glinted off of it. To the west side of the room was a set of stairs that lead to only God knows where.

There was screaming, and shouting, but the words wouldn't come back to her.

She could only remember as she sobbed and threw herself into his arms for what would be the last time.

"Please, need me! Don't let me go!" Her voiced echoed in the small room and down the stairwell. Her tears wet his shirt and in his disgust with her he pushed her away. But she fell down the stairs.

And he left her behind.

Translucent fat tears began to well in her blood eyes again. Sitting alone on the corner of the very room she died in, the beauty herself wallowed in languish. About the room was the many people she had kept as companions, only to have them starve to death later. In some brutal instances Miss Death herself had gotten a hold of them. She didn't like to recall those instances. In her corner she observed the bleached bones and rotting meat that was the remains of her last friend.

She remembered the pain she felt as this one screamed and screamed.
Having chained her up in a cage to keep her for all time, the beauty fed her little pet scraps of meat that she could find. Often, they were bits of human meat that had been lying around that was still fresh enough not to hurt the girl. Her hair had been the same violent red as the beast who had left the beauty behind.

" Please let me go! LET ME GO!" the red-head would scream over and over until she was hoarse and the beauty had to fetch her water. But this one instance of the screaming was too much; the Beauty wanted a friend to love her.

" You will love me or You will die!" The beauty's voice echoed in the grimy walls of her haunted house tomb. Running up to the change, with eyes of violent scarlet, she plunged her very hand into the chest of the captive girl. Once again, blood flowed down the arm of the beauty, and she pulled the "companion"'s heart still-beating out of her chest.

" You will love me! I will have your heart!"


Ratings
8/10
fallenseeker
Vanadia, I liked your post. Out of 10, I'll rate it an 8, for what my opinion is worth. More description of the setting would have been nice; once you establish that its a haunted house, there isn't much else. Also, I would have liked more description of the killing of the companion. I didn't really have a reaction to it, when it should have evoked something akin to revulsion. The post started out a great deal stronger then it finished. But, the style is enjoyable, you use good diction, and, overall, it paints a reasonably good picture of the scene. I'll rate this midway between literate and advanced lit.
PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 9:02 am


Well, I'll be the first one to post something, I guess. The system for posting will be, post it in the thread, and I'll copy it into the above posts for record-keeping purposes.

The background here is a fantasy-style world. The setting is the small house that the character is renting just outside a small but well-to-do village. So, please, rate and review!

fallenseeker
Tath woke up, gradually. He lay in his bed for a moment, and then pulled the blanket from his eyes, groaning a bit as the light hit his eyes through the window. “Damn…It’s still day, isn’t it.” He said, looking over at his shadow.

“Well, I’m here to answer you; what do you think, Tath?”

He pulled the blanket off the rest of his body, revealing his whole body, then rolling off the bed. “Damn…I hate waking up in the day…” What kind of vampire didn't?

His shadow laughed at him. “I don’t mind at all, it’s the only time I even get to exist.”

Tath glared at the dark shape on the floor. His shadow had a way of saying exactly what he needed to hear to get annoyed. He paced around the room, thinking about what to do for the day. “I don’t even have a feeding to look forward to tonight; I have to skip town, while they still think that buffoon is the problem.” He walked over to the trunk in the corner of the room and got himself dressed, pulling on his leather armor vest.

Shadow Tath laughed again. “Yeah, you’ve worked out a clever system over all the years,” he said as he matched his master’s every move. “Come to town, rob everyone blind, and feed when you need to. Then, when everyone suspects you, you turn the most influential man in town and desert him. The peasants catch him on his first or second attempt to feed; they see the problem is solved. That’s when you take everything you can and skip town.”

Tath only chuckled as he threw his dark robe on over the armor. “It’s been working so far; and it’s gonna work again tonight. Until then, we’ll just have to wait. Go grab the chess set. Oh, that’s right.” He got up, laughing at his shadow, pulling out the chess set and walking over to the table.

fallenseeker


Ffaux Pas
Captain

Dapper Dabbler

9,075 Points
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Brandisher 100
  • Nudist Colony 200
PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 11:19 am


Now I have a list of threads I need to reply to. -_- I'll get to posting and reviewing in this one at some point.

Just a suggestion, you may want to list the scale you'd like posts to be graded on. SemiLit-Adv, 1-10, etc?

Also, something that should be mentioned in the guidelines for the thread, are you (the submitter of the sample) looking for feedback and advice, or just to know how you rate? This goes for everyone, it's just something that should probably be included.

One more thing, should the rates/results be included with the sample in the initial reserved threads, so other people can compare their opinions of what makes a person Lit (Which would also make it easier for people to come back and check their scores occasionally if they were collected into one place) or do you prefer to leave them scattered throughout? I just don't think people will want to read the entire thread to see if anyone else has reviewed them.
PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 11:23 am


Done, done, and was already going to do it

fallenseeker


Ffaux Pas
Captain

Dapper Dabbler

9,075 Points
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Brandisher 100
  • Nudist Colony 200
PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 11:28 am


I'm still missing what scale you want used for the thread.
PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 11:34 am


when i said done, i meant "I'm about to do it."

Actually done, now.

fallenseeker


Ffaux Pas
Captain

Dapper Dabbler

9,075 Points
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Brandisher 100
  • Nudist Colony 200
PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 11:43 am


Then the term is will do -_- xD I thought you meant Done. How silly of me.

Blargh. I don't know what to post as a sample. I almost think it'd be better to post a couple, to show a little more range, but that'd just be a whole lot of text to wade through.
PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 11:44 am


Why don't you just link to your archive?

fallenseeker


Ffaux Pas
Captain

Dapper Dabbler

9,075 Points
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Brandisher 100
  • Nudist Colony 200
PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 11:52 am


Erm. Well, initially because we were C+Ping the samples into the other posts, but I guess the link could be C+Ped just as easily. The problem is, then, people need to say which post in particular they're responding to, rather than just which username. And a lot of them will look for the shortest, which will read fastest but might not be the best.

Still, here are some of them I've collected from just over the past year. What I remembered to save or can find easily.
PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 12:03 pm


Well, I'm not going to go through them for you...I've read your archive though, you had a link somewhere...its good stuff, I have to say, muuuuch better then myself.

fallenseeker


Ffaux Pas
Captain

Dapper Dabbler

9,075 Points
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Brandisher 100
  • Nudist Colony 200
PostPosted: Tue Dec 11, 2007 12:21 pm


P I'm not asking you to.

I guess since I included a minor explanation for each people can choose the one that most interests them, or just not read them at all.
Reply
Roleplays or OOC s**t

Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum