Oh, I don't think it's so bad. It's not surprising really, that another idea just fought it's way out of Sunrise. And the general response both here and across the Pacific has been positive; everyone really enjoys it so far. If you haven't checked it out,
Makoto Translations has been translating it, and
MakiMakiScanlations has been typesetting it on the original scans, so you can see all the images that go with it.
I myself am pretty pleased with it- all the characters have a fresh start (again) that suits them; I'm especially pleased with how Shizuru turned out, and the Haruka/Tomoe rivalry inspired a laugh or two. And it's nice to see Chie with her cell phone out again, and Aoi as a carefree highschooler instead of a tortured maid
sweatdrop (cmon, you know she deserved another shot).
Besides, can you blame Sunrise? This is a true moneymaker, the Mai Franchise.