mustang_slayer
I think that neither should get her cause if kyo gets her then yuki will beat the C*** out of him and if yuki gets her than kyo will snap and go crazy.
3nodding Its better if they give up on her.
3nodding But giving up on her would leave both of them lost, hurt, and lonely don't you think? I don't think they'd be open minded enough to realize that there may be other people for them out there that will accept them and their curse. Think about it, they both give up on Tohru realizing they have no chance with her. I'd say the only logical things to follow that would be depression, self loathing, the feeling of drowning with no way to escape...
Think about it!
I also disagree with you about Yuki's reaction. I think he would be extremely hurt but I still think he would respect Tohru's decision. Yuki's a pretty calm guy who doesn't go beating the s**t out of people in jealous rages.
I think she should go for Kyo. He needs someone like her in his life a lot more than Yuki does.