Defender_Of_Earth_Rose
Like I said previously I liked the idea. And it's not because I'm all Trekie fan either
stare WHY IS IT SO IMMPOSSIBLE For there to be half time Lord/Half human born natuarly? I like crossbreeding XP
Okay...I'll shut up now....
its all good. Im happy you like the idea. I myself think it goes in the face of everything the Doctor is.
One would look at the 9th Doctor calling humans "a bunch of stupid apes" and have to question why if he is half-stupid ape himself.
I also cant help but think that what makes the Doc so amazing is that he is NOT human, yet he is earth's secret defender. But if he IS half-human... then it gives his actions a new reason. He's saving his own people (so to speak). And that makes all his actions a little less heroic (at least to me).
I also have issue with the idea that he is half human and keeps it such a big secret. To me that would show he hides it. The Doctor I know and love wouldnt do that. He wouldnt have lied to all those companions (including Rose) by not telling them that.
It would be one thing if they said he was half human, and then explained WHY it was a big secret. But they didnt. Instead they had him tell some random woman that he just met (who tried to have him committed an hour earlier). Id buy it if it was "exposed" by someone that knew the truth. But to toss it out as a random previously-unknown aspect of his life? Thats just crap.
and for the record - if he was half-human (on his mother's side) that would mean he was eitehr born on earth, born in a TARDIS, or his mom (Human) gave birth to him on Galifrey. And all of which are either highly unlikely, contradicts info we had already learned about him, or conflicts with anything we know about Galifrian Society.
Reply
