Welcome to Gaia! ::

Verbal Quidditch: A Harry Potter Debate Guild

Back to Guilds

 

 

Reply Character Discussion
Mommy Issues: Narcissa Black Malfoy

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

A silly spaceholding start: Narcissa is a natural blonde.
  True!
  False!
View Results

i_heart_ron

PostPosted: Sun Dec 04, 2005 9:55 am


Narcissa Malfoy, nee Black
She's got mommy issues....


I'm endlessly fascinated by Narcissa, and not quite certain how to count the ways...

I've long argued that she is a far stronger character than we've yet had reason to suspect, to the point where she is probably more powerful, and stronger, than either her husband or sister (and I was convinced of this after Order came out). I think she wears the pants in the family. Draco's schooling and name were determined by Narcissa. Of all of Draco's sore spots, Narcissa is the one about which he is the most sensitive; he frequently boasts that he will manipulate Lucius to do this favour or pull that string, but makes no such claims about his ability to manipulate his mum. And he never calls her that. She is "mother."

She posesses a quieter, softer, less obvious brand of power, but more palpably intimidating for it. She's tightly wound, and tightly controlled, and that scares me far more than Bella's often impotent rages. The need that her family feels to protect her is facade, although they don't know that; she is perfectly content to let others feel they are in control, all the while pulling the strings.

Look at her manipulation of Snape at Spinner's End: how she plays her beauty, her expressions of helplessness against her sister's anger. Compare the vicious, righteous pureblooded fury of Bellatrix (pointedly, repeatedly rubbing Snape raw with his Muggle father's name) with Narcissa's tact. The lovely, wily pureblooded witch, grasping his ankles (classical signal of submission, gripping the back of Zeus's knees), and letting her hair spill over his lap. She's clever, she knows how to work people. Bellatrix just gets worked; she has no finesse, which is why her ability to perform or teach Occlumency surprises me greatly. Narcissa is likely a very clever Legimens. We see Bella and Lucius (and even Snape!) sputter; Narcissa never does, never falters. She's ruthless. She was even--dare I say it--classy in Madame Malkin's shop, a spectacular feat in the circumstances.

She is raw and focused Will, noun meaning volition, in the Nietzschean rather than Schopenhauerian sense (Snape is a Schopenhauerian Will), and that makes her spectacularly dangerous. When she says "there is nothing I wouldn't do anymore," I for one believe her.
PostPosted: Sun Dec 04, 2005 9:56 am


FACTS

THEORIES

i_heart_ron


i_heart_ron

PostPosted: Sun Dec 04, 2005 9:56 am


PostPosted: Sun Dec 04, 2005 10:09 am


reserved

i_heart_ron


i_heart_ron

PostPosted: Sun Dec 04, 2005 2:34 pm


NARCISSISTIC
(wow, that would've been a way better thread title?)

Jo said that Narcissa's name doesn't follow Black family convention because she's always thought of Draco's mother as a Narcissa.

The name comes, like so many constellations' names, from Greek mythology, where Narcissus became so infatuated with the beauty of his reflection that he wasted away, and was eventually tranmuted into a flower, the Narcissus. He also gave his name to the psychological disorder Narcissism, where one becomes completely obsessed with one's own superiority, to the exclusion of healthy human interactions.

Incidentally, Draco exhibits rather many of the signs of this disorder.  
PostPosted: Mon Dec 05, 2005 7:47 pm




It is, I think, very possible that Narcissa recieves a greater role in the plot of Book Seven. After all, Jo herself had said, 'There will be no new characters, only minor characters recieving larger roles.'

Has Narcissa been Marked?

Somehow, I doubt it. All of the above (extremely well-written by the way, bravo) shows her 'content[ness] to let others feel they are in control, all the while pulling the strings.' ~ i_heart_ron

This gives her a personality that says 'you may think you are dominating me, but in actuality, i am dominating you.' Would someone with this personality really let someone like (as ugly as well) Voldemort Mark her? I think not.

 

Ralph Harris The Third


i_heart_ron

PostPosted: Sun Dec 11, 2005 8:09 am


Kiyitai


It is, I think, very possible that Narcissa recieves a greater role in the plot of Book Seven. After all, Jo herself had said, 'There will be no new characters, only minor characters recieving larger roles.'

Has Narcissa been Marked?

Somehow, I doubt it. All of the above (extremely well-written by the way, bravo) shows her 'content[ness] to let others feel they are in control, all the while pulling the strings.' ~ i_heart_ron

This gives her a personality that says 'you may think you are dominating me, but in actuality, i am dominating you.' Would someone with this personality really let someone like (as ugly as well) Voldemort Mark her? I think not.

I tend to agree with this, but would reinforce that it may be vanity primarily as the indicator that she is unblemished; cite Josef Mengele, the most ruthless Nazi "doctor" (a very loose term given the "experiments" he was carrying out in the Auschwitz "hospital"); he was captured, at least twice, by Allied troops and authorities, but escaped solely because he had not been tattooed with the SS's symbol, and was turned loose. And he, personally, was responsible for far more atrocities than almost any other member of the Nazi party. But he was apparently a very handsome man (female inmates at Auschwitz referred to him as the Angel (of Death), and thus too vain to get marked as well.

apologies for tangential logic; let's talk about Cissy some more!
PostPosted: Thu Jan 19, 2006 5:03 pm


This is an interesting take on Narcissa, because I've always thought of her as she is described; docile and weak. However, thinking upon it, I think she'll be a high threat in book seven. It's possible that she is secretly close to Voldemort, and will come out as an extreme threat.

OR, she and her son could do a 180 and join Harry's side. It's possible, I thought there was some foreshadowing there when Dumbledore was stalling Draco.

[~Io~]


JewelWoods

PostPosted: Wed Feb 08, 2006 6:47 pm


User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. Click to show.
Reply
Character Discussion

 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum