Hmm. Well, I've never been religious at all and I've been a self-pronounced athiest for a long time. I don't really like the references to Christianity that Evanescence has in some of their songs. Don't get me wrong, I'm not a hater or anything. Whatever you believe is fine with me. But that just bothers me a little... When I think about it, it changes the meanings of the songs for me. An example of that would be the song October... I like to think of that song like she's speaking to a lover, not to god.
I also didn't like how John sounded when he sang "Wake Me Up Inside" when they did it live, but... He's not even with the band anymore. Haha.
That's all I can think of. I love EVERYTHING else. Lol. ;D