Exchange Item Values vs Fish/Junk Values?

[Keistera]

Here's a question that has probably been asked and answered several times for millenia, but for those that are a little thick like me...

Are we better off collecting the fish and trading them in for the exchange items, then selling said items, or selling the fish instead?
Right now, I'm mainly getting guppies and junk. (Just started, after all)

If this has been asked, then please close this and PM me instead. smile  

[Yamaryu]

In my experience it generally comes out to the same thing.  

[Cookiin]

Yamaryu

In my experience it generally comes out to the same thing.

Yeeeeaah. domokun domokun domokun  

[Wandering Child]

I've had to lower my prices and people still aren't buying fishes or helms as much as they used to... so I generally sell back guppies, trash (cept boots, saving), seedkins, and pebbos because they just get the dinky hats not the helms. I will put up for sale the others or any helms I get. Still, no takers. Has it really gone out of style already? or are there just so many now that no one needs to buy...  

[Yamaryu]

Wandering Child

I've had to lower my prices and people still aren't buying fishes or helms as much as they used to... so I generally sell back guppies, trash (cept boots, saving), seedkins, and pebbos because they just get the dinky hats not the helms. I will put up for sale the others or any helms I get. Still, no takers. Has it really gone out of style already? or are there just so many now that no one needs to buy...

Holy Crap on a Crap Cracker...a new person! (Or maybe I just haven't seen you in a while. sweatdrop Well you're new to me anyway! scream )
*cough*
There's a lot less people that want the hats, although there are new people coming in all the time and some do like the hats. Plus, we're coming out of a market flood where everyone was fishing like crazy because they could make quick cash. Things are kind of calm now and I can sell a few fish a day usually. I automatically sell all small and medium fish to Logan. I keep the junk (because I don't have the junk stuff yet) and I put up only the large fish in my shop.  

[hiro5]

ive found that the biter , tuna, and bouldur sell higher than alot of the others 3nodding ( besides the lion but still whos gonna ctach those rolleyes )  

[spacemarine140]

I dont really know...  

[Ruito]

The fish hats and helmets usually a bit harder to sell, unless you ok with selling them cheap. The latest items are more popular so if you want to exchange into items go for them.

Just collect the fish and offer to anyone who wants any items from the fish. Don't trade the fish into items yet, wait until you get good offer on the item, then you exchange the fish for the item and trade with your buyer.
If better offer comes to the fish, then you should just accept it.

If you don't need the gold that urgently, just collect the fish until the new fishing items come out.  

[colts101]

w/e