|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Feb 25, 2005 7:35 pm
(I posted this on the-ethos.org bbs earlier today, I thought since I spent a while composing it I might as well post it here too).
Being a rather big fan of the URTV characters, after playing Episode II I had begun to try to piece together some of the more vague events, and try to figure out how they fit into their own timeline and the game's timeline as a whole (partly out of curiosity, partly because I'm working on a URTV site, and partly because I want to do a doujinshi that realistically fits into the timeline). I quickly realized just how vague many of the events' times and relations to each other were. Basically, the only concrete information I've been able to figure out is that the flashback events all take place roughly 14 years ago (give or take a year or two). Not only is the timeline vague but several important events aren't really followed up on (and it seems, at least to me, that the topic of the URTV will not be expanded on in any great length later in the series) -- like what happened to Nigredo after he shoots Yuriev, and the rest of the URTV in general (I'm sure it would have had a major impact on the URTV project)? And when exactly did it happen? Before or after the main Miltian Conflict events (the Miltian Conflict is still confusing me to no end)? There are several lingering questions along these lines that I've been pondering lately and I've just reached a dead end. So I figured I'd pose the question to everyone here, maybe some of you have more sources / theories that might fill in some blanks.
So, in an attempt to create some sort of timeline I came up with a list of the flashback events from both games that had some relevance to the URTV events. I'll list them in chronological order as they appear in the game since I can't seem to put them into a decent timeline (though the events in the encephalon sequence in ep2 appear to be in roughly chronological order, though they give very limited reference to the rest of the game's events as a whole).
Episode I (these all occur during the encephalon dive, there is one scene in Jr's dream that might be relevant, but as far as I can tell it's not exactly a flashback per-say): 1- The standard type URTV are seen shooting civilians; Nigredo takes out a few of the standard types, calling for Rubedo 2- An injured Nigredo limps across the hexagonal platform, Albedo attacks him 3- Albedo, in the same hexagonal room / platform, rants to himself (the "mirror, mirror..." line)
Episode II (these occur in various parts of the game, though most take place during the encephalon dive): 4- chaos and Cannan save Rubedo and Nigredo 5- The URTV are lined up around the edge of the hexagonal platform/room, preparing to battle U-DO; Rubedo breaks the spiritual link and several units (Albedo included) become infected 6- The variant trio meet Sakura for the first time 7- Rubedo tells Juli about his meeting with sakura 8- Rubedo watches Sakura and Juli play the piano through the window, Juli discusses Sakura's condition with him 9- In Sakura's dream world Rubedo and Sakura discuss their parents; Sakura makes Rubedo promise to take care of Juli and MOMO 10- Rubedo has apparently picked up playing the harmonica; Albedo confronts Rubedo about his slipping concentration. 11- The variant trio encounters Citrine for the first time 12- The URTV prepare to dive into Sakura's subconscious to eradicate her sensory impediment; Albedo comments on the standard type URTV; the standard types question Rubedo's role as the leader 13- In Sakura's subconscious domain the URTV encounter U-DO (?) and several of the standard types are infected 14- Albedo viciously beats an unconscious standard type for attacking Rubedo; Rubedo and Nigredo stop him 15- Albedo has discovered his regenerative abilities and blows his head off in front of Rubedo and Nigredo 16- Albedo is seen digging in front of a tree; Jr. comments to the rest of the party on Albedo's altered mental state after the event just prior (discovery of his regenerative abilities) 17- The URTV prepare to dive into Sakura's subconscious domain again 18- In Sakura's subconscious domain the variant trio and Sakura return to the point where they had encountered U-DO (?) on the previous trip; Rubedo's shadow takes on an unusual shape and Albedo begins to go nuts -- Albedo(present) interrupts the flashback, thus ending the main flashback sequence 19- Citrine tells Nigredo about Red Dragon Mode 20- Nigredo shoots Dr. Dimitri Yuriev
From what I can gather events 1-5 occur during roughly the same time period (probably on the same day. Events 6-14 occur in order with minimal time between each scene. Events 15-18 seem to occur at least a short while after event 14 and probably with greater stretches of time between each consecutive event. Events 19 and 20 seem to occur in close proximity to each other in the order presented (I get the impression that Citrine's comments caused Nigredo to shoot Yuriev, and thus that they probably occurred pretty close together).
The main issue in the timeline is where exactly do these four main event segments occur in relation to each other? I can't seem to place events 1-5 in relation to 6-18 and 19&20 just don't seem to fit in anywhere. The only clues I'm aware of are that Albedo was probably contaminated with U-DO at some point during events 15-18, which seems to indicate that events 1-5 must have occurred at some point before or during that event sequence (possibly between events 14 and 15?). But given how many units were destroyed during events 1-5 (assuming that they all deal with essentially the same day/major event) and the events that occurred just after (the sealing off of Old Miltia, etc -- my knowledge of the events during the Miltian Conflict is pretty fuzzy so I've been having particular trouble placing the related URTV sequences), it's not terribly probable that events 15-18 occurred afterward. Events 19&20 have caused me nothing but problems, Yuriev's death would have probably caused an abrupt halt to the URTV project (and given that he is seen in event 17 he has to still be alive at that point).
My only vaguely plausible theory at this point is that just prior to the Miltian Conflict events (events 1-5) Nigredo shoots Yuriev (events 19&20), and that this must all occur after the major flashback sequence (events 6-1 cool . The issue of Albedo's contamination with U-DO is the only major issue with this sequence of events -- presumably his contamination occurs during event 5, and event 18 seems to indicate (by the purple glow around him when he's going nutty) that he's already been contaminated.
And then there is the question of what happened after some key events that were not delved into, like the question I posed before (it would seem like an important thing to explain) about what occurs after Nigredo shoots Yuriev. And how exactly any of this fits into the main timeline of the Miltian Conflict (Does anyone have a more detailed explanation of the events during the Conflict (or have they just not been explained yet)? It's been a source of much frustration for me over the past couple months, so any clarification at all would be appreciated).
So, does anyone have any ideas/thoughts on the subject?
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Feb 25, 2005 9:56 pm
You know, I've been trying to figure this out myself. I'm continuing Stamina and I have no idea what order everyone died in.
I'm fairly sure that Mizrahi's suicide actually took place during the Conflict, although I can't say for sure.
I haven't finished Episode II yet, so maybe I'll have a better idea of the happenings once I finish.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Feb 25, 2005 10:31 pm
If I remember correctly, Mizrahi's suicide was immediately after the revolt of the Realians on Old Miltia, which yes, would mean it happened during the Miltian Conflict.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Feb 26, 2005 8:12 am
I'm not exactly sure but I believe it goes like this.
The U.R.T.V.'s were created within the Uriev institute. Provided by Juli Mizrahi's DNA was donated for the project. Supposetly they trained together and such, and soon Jr. comes in contact with Sakura in her dream world. Then he meets her in the real world. Albedo starts getting jealous and the anger rages within and he discovers his abilities. Hence the reason why he blew up his head (minus the gun, I was so angry about that) to show off to Jr. Then soon after that they continuously meet Sakura in her dream world until Jr. and Albedo duel it out. Albedo comes to the conclusion of killing Sakura. (Translation of the Japanese game I may be wrong about this, I havn't made it this far in the english version) Then the Miltian Conflict should start up right about after Sakura dies. That's when the U.R.T.V's go to that thing and stand in a circle ready to fight U-DO. But Jr. gets scared and breaks the mental bond and then his buddies or other U.R.T.V. friends go insane. Albedo appears then the whole thing with Gaignun and finally chaos and Cannon appear. From there everything just rolls out on the red carpet.
--------------------------- Side note: Mary's accent makes me angry, and MOMO's voice sounds like a frikkn Middle School Cheerleader! RAWR! scream
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Feb 26, 2005 9:46 am
o_O Uh, Albedo did not freak because of jealousy regarding Sakura. That much I'm confident about. Even if it were the case, it would be a minor secondary factor. Albedo's insanity was brought about by the realization of his immortality--there was a quote Jin provided regarding the fact that without death, life becomes a prison. That would be the catalyst the eventually led to all of his other actions.
He did not "show off," however. It was simply a matter of confusion--prior to when he blew his own head off, he was under the impression that all of the U.R.T.V. could simply regenerate upon death, which was why he acted so harshly, physically, toward the mass produced model. When Rubedo and Nigredo were confused, Albedo obliged to show them what he was referring to. It wasn't so much arrogance at the time as it was ignorance and naivety.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Feb 26, 2005 10:34 am
Well, the one thing I'm terribly confused over is when Albedo gets contaminated by U-DO. If I can place that event the rest sort of makes sense. You see, in the scene where Albedo is digging (in the encephalon) we don't hear what he's saying/thinking until we see the scene again in the Local Matter Shift (very end, it's Albedo's version of the event -- sort of -- so we hear what he's saying) and he's going on about practicing digging graves for when Rubedo and Nigredo die so that he won't be sad, but then he mentions "if I link with U-DO again..." If I can assume that these two scenes (Jr's version from the encephalon and Albedo's version in the LMS -- though if I'm quoting that wrong that could be the problem too) are essentially the same, but from different perspectives, then, presumably it means that Albedo has already been contaminated by U-DO in that scene (now the rest of this sort of hinges on the fact that I'm assuming that the sequences in the encephalon dive are roughly in chornological order). However, I've been under the impression that Albedo isn't contaminated until the Miltian Conflict thing where Rubedo breaks the mental link -- so either there's a descrepencey somewhere in the timeline, or I've made too many assumptions about the order of things (and/or the connection between the encephalon and LMS scene that I just mentioned). So that's one big issue, placing Albedo's contamination with U-DO. The second big problem is when Nigredo kills Yuriev. It had to have occured after the events of the main flashback sequence, because Yuriev is still seen alive in one of the last scenes. The only place I think it might fit is just prior to the Miltian Conflict events or even during the events (maybe just after the link is broken, Nigredo makes it back to the Institute, Citrine catches him and explains stuff -- presumably in relation to what Rubedo was talking about just prior to cutting the link -- causing Nigredo to go shoot Yuriev, which may be how he got injured -- though it is shown in episode 1 that Albedo does attack him -- so maybe he came back to tell Rubedo what had happend or something *has lost her train of thought*). So that's the next confusing point.
Everything else would probably make sense if I could just place these two events. I think the only one that'll be expanded on later is Nigredo's killing of Yuriev, they seem to be done with Albedo as far as backstory is concerned.
In response to the brief discussion over Albedo's jealousy of Sakura. I would have to agree that he's jealous of her but because he's "in love" with Rubedo. Having been conjoined twins Rubedo and Albedo are very close, Albedo seems to have been unusually attached to Rubedo because he was a bit more timid than his brother and Rubedo probably always protected him. When Sakura comes around, Rubedo starts spending a lot of time with her that he probably would have usually spent with his brothers. Naturally, Albedo gets jealous because he's not recieving as much attention as before; it probably went as far as to make Albedo feel very insecure about his relationship with Rubedo -- he's probably wondering what he did or if Rubedo now hates him for some reason (sounds pretty realistic for a 12 year old if you ask me). Now, when he starts beating up the standard type I believe he's trying to show off to Rubedo, in the sense that -- yes, he probably thinks that they all have the same abilities (so he's not really hurting him), but that he thinks that he's teaching the standard type a lesson not to go against Rubedo (he defends Rubedo on another occasion against the standard types too) in order that he would win back Rubedo's favor (again, he probably thinks that Rubedo doesn't like him as much anymore because he's not spending as much time with him as he used to). But when Albedo blows his head off in front of Rubedo and Nigredo he's probably just trying to explain why he didn't think it was so bad to hurt the other units (he was probably especially confused when Rubedo scolds him after telling him to stop beating the standard type, "You'll kill him!"). And from that point, when he learns that he's essentially immortal, his mental state starts to deteroriate rather rapidly, as he wasn't totally mentaly sound to begin with at that point (already terribly insecure, and fearing that he'll be left alone by Rubedo in favor of Sakura, but he probably was clinging to the idea that if Rubedo was also imortal like him that Sakura would die eventually and things could go back to the way they were before they had met Sakura, but realizing that he was the only one that would die only amplified his insecurity of being alone, or rather solidified the fear as an inevatible reality that he would have to face eventually). Naturally U-DO doesn't help Albedo's mental state either.
[EDIT] Woah, I didn't realize just how long this post was... I need to learn to be more concise >.<
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Feb 26, 2005 4:35 pm
Well, yes, jealousy in that sense would be the case. But jealousy wouldn't really be the best word to use. The most adequate term would be something along the lines of spite toward her. -shrug.- Either could work, but I was simply referring to the typical context of jealousy.
As for Albedo's contamination--that's fairly clear to be when they attempted to contain U-DO. The two events, I can probably safely say, were the same. Not necessarily from different perspectives but rather the first time we saw the event, we were simply seeing the flashback, as it happened, no strings attached and no interference. When we saw it during the space-time anomaly, what we were actually viewing was one where both Rubedo's and Albedo's conciousness were present and interacting, not in the past but in the present, which was why the two were percieved differently.
Last, the importance of where Dmitri Yuriev's death should be fairly negligable. It doesn't specify a time as it isn't important. I really don't see any way to pick and put it at any point relative to the others. If I had to guess, however, I would say that it happened prior to their trip to Old Miltia to tackle U-DO. At the end of the game, if you remember, when Albedo was talking to Rubedo, Albedo informed him to watch Nigredo's shadow, to consider why Nigredo is immune to U-DO's contamination. This basically suggests that Yuriev's invasion into Nigredo's conciousness as he did it somehow influences the fact that Nigredo was not infected when U-DO broke free on Old Miltia fourteen years prior.
On the other hand, like I said, it'd be hard to place the event. Yuriev is being portrayed as quite the planner--a schemer with everything he had in mind to happen set long before (which I believe qualifies him quite well as potentially being the pale horseman). I'd say it is just as likely that Yuriev, knowing that he would perhaps need to be closer to the U.R.T.V. to really have the most adequate grasp on the events to come, intentionally made Nigredo immune by whatever factors it would take to insure Nigredo's survival and stability following any failure on Old Miltia.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Feb 27, 2005 7:12 am
Aww Hellish we're having a discussion not a debate. You should really stop trashing other people's idea's and instead accept and edit them like Shoku-san.
Anyway, I did forget that important detail about Nigredo killing Yuriev, I don't understand how Yuriev is inside Nigredo though, technically it's impossible... wait nvm. It is possible, just think about the Hulk in a sense. Except since Yuriev is father to the U.R.T.V.'s his cells are apart of them. Still a little confusing, anyone have any ideas?
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Feb 27, 2005 8:41 am
Man. o.o I didn't trash anyone's idea. As it's a discussion, I just added my viewpoint that did not fully agree and I did so fairly politely. If I don't agree with them I should not accept them but I was not rude about how I handled it.
Onto how that would be possible, I suspect it could have been done similarly to what happens in an encephalon dive, where their conciousness essentially enters the individual's subconcious. If, somehow, Yuriev were able to enter Gaignun's mind in an encephalon dive, somewhere or somehow, perhaps by just lingering in the encephalon, he could feasibly have gained access to Nigredo's mind.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Feb 27, 2005 12:13 pm
But Yuriev is dead, and the encephalon dive is essentially a program. How could he access it if he's dead?
EDIT:
Just thinking slightly, Hopefully we have no FFX-2 Repeat and have Yuriev just being a shadow that can take over people. If that's the case then I'll end up writing a strong letter to Namco about that =(
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Feb 27, 2005 6:19 pm
No. He wouldn't be a shadow that can take people over. As the U.R.T.V. had a significant amount of training in the encephalon, he could have easily returned with Nigredo during one of the sessions, perhaps following his death (although to be completely sure is hard to do).
The encephalon is just a program, yes, but the encephalon is a program that basically rips your conciousness out of your body and places it into someone else's conciousness or possibly even a programmed location. So therefore, Dmitri could have easily had his conciousness completely separated from his body and present somewhere int he encephalon program awaiting an opportunity to enter Nigredo's subconciousness.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Feb 27, 2005 6:35 pm
Are you sure theres any facts regaurding that the Encephalon does exactly what you say?
Because Shion was pretty conscious when she first did the Encephalon Dive in Xenosaga Episode I. You can't just say anything like that without some pretty hard evidence to follow on.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Feb 27, 2005 6:43 pm
As much as I can provide. It does not necessarily make the person on the outside completely unconcious. But when they dove into Shion's subconcious, they were clearly going into her subconcious, there's no doubt about that. Obviously that's what the encephalon does. As they are there capable of making decisions, thinking, and essentially acting inside one another's head, their conciousness is present.
In the case of the first dive, there's good reason, as well, why she was laying down. Her conciousness and all the decisions made were made while active in KOS-MOS' system from the system suggesting that her body was fairly unresponsive on the outside.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|