Welcome to Gaia! ::

Guild of Vegans and Vegetarians

Back to Guilds

Join vegetarians and supporters for discussion on health, cooking, and ethical issues! 

Tags: Food, Vegan, Vegetarian, Animal, Cooking 

Reply Chatterbox
Vegan or vegetarian? Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Mrs Joe Trohman

PostPosted: Mon May 29, 2006 8:18 am


I am just a vegetarian because I love cheese and milk to much to give it up.
PostPosted: Mon May 29, 2006 12:28 pm


Me too. I never felt something for being a vegan and being a vegetarian is good enough for me.

Lisanneliz


Soymilk_Gun

PostPosted: Mon May 29, 2006 7:19 pm


so would you say you love cheese and milk more or less than you love raping and killing cows?

And dont forget the chickens strung out on speed, abused, and killed for you eggs?

Or the honeybees starved or crushed for your honey and wax

http://veg.gs/dateien/wiki/05pr.jpg
PostPosted: Mon May 29, 2006 9:27 pm


Soymilk, you are exactly one reason why so many people hate veg*ns. You're too damn hostile and preachy. It's someone's choice. Not yours. I understand your right to an opinion, but your hostility hit a nerve for me.

Ailinea
Vice Captain


Soymilk_Gun

PostPosted: Tue May 30, 2006 10:37 pm


When did torture, rape, and murder become merely personal choices? I may be a a*****e...Ok I am an a*****e but I'll take hurting some feelings and losing friends over being complicit in torture and genocide. Its not some vegans being assholes that stop many people from goign veg....its that many folks just dont care about non-humans There entire world view is based on human supierority and their culture reinforces that at every turn. They arent going to change because you ask them nicly to respect the rights of those who they firmly beleive to have no rights.
I think 200 billion murders a year justifies a bit of anger and hostility. If folks dont like being called murderers then maybe they should stop killing for their own damn pleasure. Thats what strikes a nerve with me, peoples tendecy to hold their desire for a slice of cheese pizza as more importants than a cow's life. That kind of arrogance is far more destructive than my arrogance?

Sure dairy products are yummy but is your pleasure really worth their suffering?
PostPosted: Wed May 31, 2006 8:04 am


It has nothing to do with people not caring about "non-humans." My goal in life is to fight for animals. I'm going to college so that I can major in wildlife management so that I can help the animals fight back. I just completed an internship in California working 12 hour days in the 100 degree desert heat restoring countless illegal trails so that the endangered desert tortoise might have a fighting change against these arrogant humans you speak of.

If you opened up your eyes you'd see that not everyone can do a diet like you can. Some people could die if they adopted a vegan diet. Personally, I've gone vegetarian I don't know how many times. Want to know what stopped me? Massive, excrutiatingly painful chest pains that made me to want to die. On a recommendation, I started eating meat again. Since then, no chest pains. I only eat meat occasionally, just so I don't have to suffer anymore. I can't afford a doctor, medication, or expensive dieticians. Unfortunately, biology fields don't pay much. And I'll have to deal with it.

What am I getting at? People DO care, no matter what your close-minded opinion may be. It only pisses me off more when people like you try to shove it in my face even more when THERE'S NOTHING I CAN DO ABOUT IT. Talking to other friends who are omnivores, and hell, even other friends who are vegan or vegetarian, they agree that hostile attitudes like yours make people WANT to eat meat more, just to spite you. It's that attitude that spurs organizations like PETA... People Eating Tasty Animals. The hostility, if anything, only seems to make things worse, in my opinion, and in others.

I'm not saying there's not a problem. There is a HUGE problem with factory farming. It needs to be rid of. I would like to be alive to see its destruction. But once animals are put out in pastures, chickens are kept in large yards with grass, chicken feed, soft bundles of straw to lay in, and plenty of room to run around in, cows are being fed corn and other natural things without the injections and hormones, being milked once a day and only when they have calves, not to force them to have them, then what? The animals are living healthy existences. They are in large fields where they can run and eat until their heart's content. They wouldn't be mass bred, but like farms of years ago. Would you still have a problem then? Probably. But you can't cure factory farming over night. I don't see the world EVER switching to all vegans. It's just not going to happen. Cows, chickens, pigs, all livestock in general couldn't survive without human influence. It was us who bred them after all.

Let me ask you this: Do you have a problem with how some native american tribes or early homo-sapien clans worshipped animals and worked with them before going on a hunt? They never farmed them. They only killed if needed, and when they did, they used EVERY part of the animal. They did it for survival. What do you think?

Ailinea
Vice Captain


..lil minx 3..

PostPosted: Wed May 31, 2006 8:42 am


i'm just a vegetarian
PostPosted: Wed May 31, 2006 9:00 am


Quote:
I think 200 billion murders a year justifies a bit of anger and hostility. If folks dont like being called murderers then maybe they should stop killing for their own damn pleasure. Thats what strikes a nerve with me, peoples tendecy to hold their desire for a slice of cheese pizza as more importants than a cow's life. That kind of arrogance is far more destructive than my arrogance?


So you actually think being nasty like you are is going to get people to see your view? No, It's going to turn them away. Why do you think so many people have problems with fundamentalist Christians? The ONLY way of getting people to understand is to show some understanding and compassion. I won't write anymore to you simply because there is no point. Ailinea, you are such a good person! People like you are the ones who inspire others to do great things in life.

Henbane
Vice Captain


Ailinea
Vice Captain

PostPosted: Wed May 31, 2006 9:38 am


Wow, thanks, Henbane, glad someone could see my side. And the compliment is overwhelming. redface

But I have to give a pat on the back for the fundie analogy. You're right, it's exactly the same.
PostPosted: Wed May 31, 2006 11:52 am


Soymilk_Gun
When did torture, rape, and murder become merely personal choices? I may be a a*****e...Ok I am an a*****e but I'll take hurting some feelings and losing friends over being complicit in torture and genocide.

Is a lion who eats gazelle a murderer?

Being a lacto-vegetarian doesn't mean someone likes "raping and killing cows". A lacto-vegetarian has already taken a big step away from hurting animals. Rather than insinuating that she's depraved, I think you should stop being so goddamn judgemental. She's doing more than a non-vegetarian, why can't you be satisfied with that??

Quote:

Its not some vegans being assholes that stop many people from goign veg....its that many folks just dont care about non-humans
Wanna bet? I can't offer proof any more than you can, but I can't even begin to count the number of people who are anti-vegan because they're sick of being judged and preached at! Shoving your views down our throats is not going to make us sympathetic.

Quote:
There entire world view is based on human supierority and their culture reinforces that at every turn.
You say human superiority, I say a human dependancy and lack of education and/or options. Don't act as if you know what goes on in everyone else's head, because you don't.
Quote:
They arent going to change because you ask them nicly to respect the rights of those who they firmly beleive to have no rights.

Since when is it even remotely ok to demand that everyone follow YOUR system of beliefs? Making suggestions and educating people is not the same as aggressively insisting that you know what's best for everyone.

Quote:

I think 200 billion murders a year justifies a bit of anger and hostility. If folks dont like being called murderers then maybe they should stop killing for their own damn pleasure.

First: Do you not understand that not everyone believes it is murder? You're clearly not an idiot, so why is that so hard for you to follow? Calling people murderers is not going to make them listen to you. They're just going to stop listening.

Secondly, assuming that everyone can be vegan is very, very close-minded. There's a plethora of reasons why we can't all be vegan; and you know what? Not a single one of those reasons is any of your business.

Live your life, and don't try to live other people's lives for them.

Quote:

Thats what strikes a nerve with me, peoples tendecy to hold their desire for a slice of cheese pizza as more importants than a cow's life. That kind of arrogance is far more destructive than my arrogance?

What strikes a nerve for me is that you are absolutely intolerant of anyone else's beliefs. It's unfortunate that an animal is caught up in this, but go eat your vegan cheese and put up posters and let people make their own decisions. After all, if they truly have a reason to feel guilty, it'll catch up with them when they die.

Not everyone can be vegan. Your beliefs do not trump those of anyone else. Being hostile isn't going to do a bit of good.

End of story.

Taeryyn

Man-Hungry Ladykiller


Ailinea
Vice Captain

PostPosted: Wed May 31, 2006 12:21 pm


I love you, Ciel. Nicely said. Perhaps I should move this to ED? xP
PostPosted: Thu Jun 01, 2006 1:22 am


Quote:
Some people could die if they adopted a vegan diet.

There is no essential nutrient for humans found in animal flesh that can not be gotten from plant sources as part of a regular diet. If you are having a problem with exculding meat from your diet because of medical reasons then you could atleast give up dairy, eggs, honey, and all other animal products. Or do you get really sick when you take dairy away also. Well then you could still exclude those...or are the necessary too? Every little bit helps. It dosent make sense to advocate for animal rights or liberation and still enjoy food produced under horrible conditions. For the most part folks make a concious decision what to eat everyday...they have the choice to not eat animal products if they beleive animals have rights in some shape or form the it only logically follows that they would make a simple choice and if you live with ur parents, you obviously are able to stand up for you beliefs here why not to ur parents?

Quote:
People DO care, no matter what your close-minded opinion may be.

Sure there are lots of people who do care (lots that dont too) but a good number of those that care dont seem to care enough to make aditional lifestyle changes and continue to gain pleasure from animal products produced in harmful conditions.

Quote:
Let me ask you this: Do you have a problem with how some native american tribes or early homo-sapien clans worshipped animals and worked with them before going on a hunt? They never farmed them. They only killed if needed, and when they did, they used EVERY part of the animal. They did it for survival. What do you think?

Unless it purly a matter of survival then it is causeing suffering and death unnecessarily. And yes Ive got a problem with that. If you have to take life to prevent your own death then go ahead, its a pretty natural and understandable thing to do but if you can gather enough nutrients and calories from plant sources then you dont need to hurt and kill animals.

Quote:
Is a lion who eats gazelle a murderer?

No more than a three year old that accidentally shoots someone with what it thinks is a toy (keep your guns out of childrens reach folks)
Lions lack the ability to reason morally and weight the bad effects of their actions against the benifits. Also they hunt and kill out of instict and for survival.


Quote:
Since when is it even remotely ok to demand that everyone follow YOUR system of beliefs? Making suggestions and educating people is not the same as aggressively insisting that you know what's best for everyone.

I dont really care much what folks beleive as long as those beleifs dont result in unnecessary suffering. When your belief causes an innocent animal to be abused or killed then the animals rights to trump your "right" to eat animal flesh. This isnt a nice clean battle of ideas. Some of these ideas leave billions dead.

Soymilk_Gun


Taeryyn

Man-Hungry Ladykiller

PostPosted: Thu Jun 01, 2006 7:18 am


Soymilk_Gun

There is no essential nutrient for humans found in animal flesh that can not be gotten from plant sources as part of a regular diet. If you are having a problem with exculding meat from your diet because of medical reasons then you could atleast give up dairy, eggs, honey, and all other animal products. Or do you get really sick when you take dairy away also. Well then you could still exclude those...or are the necessary too? Every little bit helps. It dosent make sense to advocate for animal rights or liberation and still enjoy food produced under horrible conditions. For the most part folks make a concious decision what to eat everyday...they have the choice to not eat animal products if they beleive animals have rights in some shape or form the it only logically follows that they would make a simple choice and if you live with ur parents, you obviously are able to stand up for you beliefs here why not to ur parents?

Where I live, it is NOT POSSIBLE for me to OBTAIN the non-meat, non-dairy foods I would need to BE VEGAN. Even if I WANTED to be vegan, I couldn't. Many people who are from the US or urban areas just can't seem to understand that there are thousands of people living in areas where there are no boca burgers, vegan cheese, or vegetarian alternatives, PERIOD.
Now, even if such food was available, my parents have no problem with me being veg. The issue is MONEY. We can't afford to buy seperate food for me to eat.

I'd just like to add that not all milk, cheese, or eggs come from factory farms. We get our milk and cheese products from local farmers. These aren't factory farms, and the cows aren't hooked up to machines all day. The eggs my family (not me) eats come from a family friend who has a handful of pet chickens. They're free-range and are treated like family members.

For all your talk of choice, you don't seem to accept the choices other people have made, or the fact that some of us do not have a choice. If every little bit helps, then stop harassing people who are simply vegetarian.


Quote:

Sure there are lots of people who do care (lots that dont too) but a good number of those that care dont seem to care enough to make aditional lifestyle changes and continue to gain pleasure from animal products produced in harmful conditions.
As we've already explained, it's not necessarily a choice. Secondly, they care enough to be vegetarian. They *are* saving animals; being critical of their "efforts" is discouraging and unnecessary.

Quote:

No more than a three year old that accidentally shoots someone with what it thinks is a toy (keep your guns out of childrens reach folks)
Lions lack the ability to reason morally and weight the bad effects of their actions against the benifits. Also they hunt and kill out of instict and for survival.

Being vegan isn't an option for lions, and it's not an option for some humans. Deal with it.


Quote:

I dont really care much what folks beleive as long as those beleifs dont result in unnecessary suffering. When your belief causes an innocent animal to be abused or killed then the animals rights to trump your "right" to eat animal flesh. This isnt a nice clean battle of ideas. Some of these ideas leave billions dead.

But you do care! PersonX doesn't believe that eating dairy products is hurting a cow. PersonX doesn't believe that honey should be excluded from his vegan diet. PersonX doesn't believe that the cow from which his hamburger came was treated badly.

I'm all for education. Many people don't know what goes on in the meat industry, and I think it's great that people such as yourself want to let them know about the atrocities. But you can educate them all you want, and people are still going to make choices that you don't necessarily agree with.

Soymilk, believe me, I wish we lived in a world where animals didn't have to suffer. But being agressive and verbally violent is not a solution to any problem.

Really, this whole thing is similar to the abortion issue, so no wonder it's such a heated argument. X3
PostPosted: Thu Jun 01, 2006 9:54 am


Soymilk_Gun
so would you say you love cheese and milk more or less than you love raping and killing cows?

And dont forget the chickens strung out on speed, abused, and killed for you eggs?

Or the honeybees starved or crushed for your honey and wax

http://veg.gs/dateien/wiki/05pr.jpg


Cows are not "tortured" for milk unless the owner is a jackass. Chickens are not "strung out on speed" for eggs unless, as I said earlier, the owner is a jackass. And for your information my familly is buying free range chicken eggs now. You're free to your to think whatever you want to think but please do not force your beliefs onto others.

Mrs Joe Trohman


Mrs Joe Trohman

PostPosted: Thu Jun 01, 2006 10:00 am


Ailinea
Soymilk, you are exactly one reason why so many people hate veg*ns. You're too damn hostile and preachy. It's someone's choice. Not yours. I understand your right to an opinion, but your hostility hit a nerve for me.


Thankyou so much! biggrin
Reply
Chatterbox

Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum