"Your comic sucks" STFU! It's AWESOME | Page 1 | Webcomic Creators | Guild Forums

Gaia Guilds

The Guild of Webcomics and Awesome.

Back to Guilds

Webcomic Creators

"Your comic sucks" STFU! It's AWESOME

Mad.Scientist.Miz

Offline

Posted: Tue Aug 08, 2006 1:48 am

So I've been applying for transplant comics hosting, and they post their applications in the forums - didn't know this until after - and now I feel like s**t because currently, 4 out of 4 people do not think my comic should not be hosted at all.

OKAY, so they aren't being "cruel" about it, but I'm being shot down here! WTF?

Whatever, I think my webcomic is awesome. I'm still going to try my best like in every comic I do, and I know there are people out there that like it too. SCREW TRANSPLANT COMICS! I'm a webcomic genius.

Here is a link to what Transplant Comic Forums had to say about mt webcomic.

Here is a link to my tripod hosted website.

Posted: Tue Aug 08, 2006 7:09 am

I'd never even heard of that Transplant place before this. XD;
But I like your comic.
You probably wouldn't wanna host it at a place that's close-minded like that anyway... I'd suggest Smackjeeves, but there are other suggestions at that sticky Profile made

Nikki is Missing
Captain

Offline

[Larn]
Crew

Offline

Posted: Wed Aug 09, 2006 7:48 am

I like your comic, but I still think it has room to mature before trying to get on a bigger webcomic host. It doesn't suck by any means, but I suggest reading a lot of webcomics and seeing the standards that are set, and things you could improve about your own.

Posted: Tue Sep 19, 2006 5:36 am

Why not comic genesis? Its free and it has the auto update feature? Or Smack Jeeves?

Blitz_Blazer

Offline

dead.moki

Offline

Posted: Tue Sep 26, 2006 6:48 pm

While they were pretty rude about it, it seemed like the main reason was because you only gave a character sheet as an example instead of several comic pages so they could really evaluate the comic.

Posted: Wed Sep 27, 2006 11:53 am

They must be mental.

Your comics ARE the awesome.

Yeah. cool

Nightmare_iLussen

Offline

ravnosgod

Offline

Posted: Sun Oct 15, 2006 6:02 pm

I enjoyed your comic as well

Posted: Mon Oct 16, 2006 10:08 am

Alright, I read your comic and then read through your critics replies...

All I have to say is that this comic has potential but you need to work on it a bit more. (Please don't take anything I say beyond this point personally, I'm trying to help by giving you area's to work on. Not insult or belittle your tallent.)

I believe the art could be cleaned up a bit. The lines look to much like they were just slapped on with msn paint. If you'd like I could link you to a tutorial for inking comics. It explains everything real well and gives detailed instructions.
Also the anatomy of your characters is a bit.. iffy. Mind you this is just my personal opinion but I think it would look better if they had... elbows, knee's, hips perhaps?

I think the characters are good, especially the cat. ^_^ That was cute.

Um... besides that, I think you need to start working on story-lines. Unless you're going for a one shot joke in each panel there should be a slightly deeper plot going on.

Besides that I think this is a great comic! Congrats!