|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 30, 2006 6:02 am
Well, I was recently reading one of Imotoku's posts that mentioned abortion. He actually said that abortion discussions were exhausting, so I figured "I'll start up a abortion discussion." I personally think that abortion is alright. Not doing an abortion could really mess your life up. On the other hand, if don't want a child, you should have stopped it one stage earlier. I still think that it's fine. Partially because, taking birth control and stopping a lifeform from developing is just the same as getting rid of a lifeform that's only just begining life. So, that's the first topic: abortion.
So, second, I saw a bumper sticker yesterday that said "You Can't Be Pro-Life and Pro-War." I thought that was really cool. How can oppose the killing of a few couple-celled organisms and support the killing and take-over of a whole country of people. You can also discuss Pro-life, is that really what it is? So go wild.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 30, 2006 7:45 am
Thanks a lot stare .
So anyways, I guess I can't use the Bible to defend myself against you. Well I believe abortion is wrong. Life is there, in my opinion, as soon as it is concieved it is life. If it dies naturally then well.....then it dies.
Okay, scientists can bring people back from clinical death, though not long after death. That is when your heart and brain stops. Many people have come out of clinical death after turning cold and all your readings flatline, without the aid of scientists. Some up to an hour after clinical death. So what is true death? Death is when your soul leaves your body.
So what is life? When your soul enters your body. So to find out if abortion is wrong you have to find out when true life is, that is when your soul is in your body.(fat chance figuring that out) Remeber the Bible says the body without the soul is dead.
That is my opinion anyways.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 30, 2006 8:27 am
That's a sounds opinion. A baby that's not even the size of... a grain of rice, can't think, can't really feel, and won't remember any of this when is does come out might have a soul. However, even if it does happen to have a soul at that point, won't it just go back up and look for a new host for its spirit? It was dead before it had any form of life. This, to me, is the same as having no baby in the first place. Babies are sometimes dead when they're born, that's not all that differant than abortion, its just a different form of death. If God wanted all babies to be born, why do so many die on their own?
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 30, 2006 11:41 am
Dr. Kool That's a sounds opinion. A baby that's not even the size of... a grain of rice, can't think, can't really feel, and won't remember any of this when is does come out might have a soul. However, even if it does happen to have a soul at that point, won't it just go back up and look for a new host for its spirit? It was dead before it had any form of life. This, to me, is the same as having no baby in the first place. Babies are sometimes dead when they're born, that's not all that differant than abortion, its just a different form of death. If God wanted all babies to be born, why do so many die on their own? Look it's not an opinion, abortion is killing lives and taking away the chance for that baby to grow up and maybe even make a difference in someone else's life. Face it, i don't care if u think it's an opinion, a fact is a fact.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 30, 2006 12:09 pm
I'm pro-choice. That doesn't mean I'm a heartless baby killer. I'm pro-life personally, I would never ever want to have an abortion myself.
If you really can't support a child, then abortion should be an available option. Yes, they can put the child up for adoption, but not every child is adopted by Angelina Jolie and giving birth permanently changes your body. The adoption system is overflowing, many foster parents are abusive. I heard a story about a woman who fostered all these children and kept them in her attic licking stamps all day long. The idea that every child put up for adoption will be welcomed with open arms by a couple who was so sad that they couldn't have children of their own is a myth.
A fetus really doesn't care if you abort it, since it doesn't even have cognition until later in the pregnancy. I'm only pro-choice to the point of viability, or when it can survive outside the womb.
I agree you shouldn't be having lots of irresponsible sex when you can't support a child, but not everyone who wants/needs an abortion is an irresponsible teenage girl who just didn't use protection. In fact most abortions aren't done on teenagers.
Illegal abortions are dangerous, and abortions are going to keep happening whether we make abortion illegal or not. The number of women that die from abortions has dropped from hundred (I don't remember the exact statistic) to just a few now.
No one is debating whether abortions are good or not, everyone knows abortions are bad. In a perfect world, we wouldn't need abortion. But the world's not perfect and women should have the right to choose.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 30, 2006 12:19 pm
I only think that abortion should be done in the case of rape or incest, or if the mother's life is in danger. Then again, I'm a little tired of people using abortion as birth control. THAT makes me angry. A new life is growing, but will never have the chance to make something of that life. Human life, to me, is sacred, even if it's just a few cells when you first look at it. Killing anything that will grow into a baby, into another human being, is wrong to me. That doesn't mean I'm going to the nearest abortion clinic and damning the murderers to hell. My views differ from theirs, and pro-choice and pro-life will never quite see eye-to-eye. In fact, there's a big to-do going on in my state (South Dakota) over this very issue. *sigh*
My personal idea on it: Make abortion clinics into places you go when referred by a doctor. For one, if it's not readily available as a walk-in, more people might have safer sex. For another, you'll need a legitimate reason to get rid of a child. Course, that would probably be protested too.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 30, 2006 12:26 pm
Dr. Kool So, second, I saw a bumper sticker yesterday that said "You Can't Be Pro-Life and Pro-War." I thought that was really cool. How can oppose the killing of a few couple-celled organisms and support the killing and take-over of a whole country of people. Yep, supporting the deposing of ruthless dictators and terrorists just can't happen when you value innocent human life. rolleyes
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 30, 2006 12:30 pm
Captain_Theoretical I'm pro-choice. That doesn't mean I'm a heartless baby killer. I'm pro-life personally, I would never ever want to have an abortion myself. If you really can't support a child, then abortion should be an available option. Yes, they can put the child up for adoption, but not every child is adopted by Angelina Jolie and giving birth permanently changes your body. The adoption system is overflowing, many foster parents are abusive. I heard a story about a woman who fostered all these children and kept them in her attic licking stamps all day long. The idea that every child put up for adoption will be welcomed with open arms by a couple who was so sad that they couldn't have children of their own is a myth. A fetus really doesn't care if you abort it, since it doesn't even have cognition until later in the pregnancy. I'm only pro-choice to the point of viability, or when it can survive outside the womb. I agree you shouldn't be having lots of irresponsible sex when you can't support a child, but not everyone who wants/needs an abortion is an irresponsible teenage girl who just didn't use protection. In fact most abortions aren't done on teenagers. Illegal abortions are dangerous, and abortions are going to keep happening whether we make abortion illegal or not. The number of women that die from abortions has dropped from hundred (I don't remember the exact statistic) to just a few now.
No one is debating whether abortions are good or not, everyone knows abortions are bad. In a perfect world, we wouldn't need abortion. But the world's not perfect and women should have the right to choose. Do u know that ppl don't go to a pregnant woman and ask "How's ur fetus doing?" they ask her "How's ur baby doing?" or "did u feel the baby kick yet?", ppl use "fetus" when the baby is unwanted or when talking about abortion but when it's wanted it's called a baby, i wonder why ..... *wonders*
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 30, 2006 12:44 pm
Like I said we have no idea when the spirit actually becomes 1 with the body.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 30, 2006 12:47 pm
Dr. Kool That's a sounds opinion. A baby that's not even the size of... a grain of rice, can't think, can't really feel, and won't remember any of this when is does come out might have a soul. However, even if it does happen to have a soul at that point, won't it just go back up and look for a new host for its spirit? It was dead before it had any form of life. This, to me, is the same as having no baby in the first place. Babies are sometimes dead when they're born, that's not all that differant than abortion, its just a different form of death. If God wanted all babies to be born, why do so many die on their own? We wont remeber, but that doesn't mean it does not think. The highest proof I find that a body does not live unless a spirit is in it is the jellyfish. With no brain, heart, blood, bones, or lungs, and yet it eats and moves. That shows living things need a soul to really live. The baby would not find a new "host" it would be dead. It would most likely be in Heaven. A soul must be there to live. When the soul is part of the flesh is a mystery to me. You don't know if God wanted all babies to be born. Who knows the mind of God? God himself. Everything happens for a reason and everything that happens is under control. That does not mean everything is right because we as humans have free will, including going against God's will.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 30, 2006 12:48 pm
Cometh The Inquisitor Dr. Kool So, second, I saw a bumper sticker yesterday that said "You Can't Be Pro-Life and Pro-War." I thought that was really cool. How can oppose the killing of a few couple-celled organisms and support the killing and take-over of a whole country of people. Yep, supporting the deposing of ruthless dictators and terrorists just can't happen when you value innocent human life. rolleyes Supporting pro-choice and the death penalty? Kill off those innocent children, but let the murderer live. xd
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 30, 2006 12:57 pm
thejesusfreak Dr. Kool That's a sounds opinion. A baby that's not even the size of... a grain of rice, can't think, can't really feel, and won't remember any of this when is does come out might have a soul. However, even if it does happen to have a soul at that point, won't it just go back up and look for a new host for its spirit? It was dead before it had any form of life. This, to me, is the same as having no baby in the first place. Babies are sometimes dead when they're born, that's not all that differant than abortion, its just a different form of death. If God wanted all babies to be born, why do so many die on their own? Look it's not an opinion, abortion is killing lives and taking away the chance for that baby to grow up and maybe even make a difference in someone else's life. Face it, i don't care if u think it's an opinion, a fact is a fact. Look freako, nothing is fact unless it can be proven with the scientific method. You say that killing a baby is taking away a chance for it to grow up, however, not having a baby in the first place not allowing it grow up. Same deal, dude. Just because I support the idea of abortion, I'm not a baby-murdering sociopath. I don't think that its good, I just think that people should have the option. Oh, and face it, just because an old book tells you its wrong doesn't mean that its so. Fact is fact. As far as Catian Theoretical and ryuu's ideas go, I agree. ryuu especially, I really should have said that in first place. You need a good reason to get rid of the baby. Also, abortion is one of those things that is your personal choice and shouldn't be controlled by other people. Its your baby that's not going to be there, not theirs'. Its your joy that you're missing when you get rid of the chance to have a child of your own. Its not their baby to miss out on.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 30, 2006 1:04 pm
Dr. Kool thejesusfreak Dr. Kool That's a sounds opinion. A baby that's not even the size of... a grain of rice, can't think, can't really feel, and won't remember any of this when is does come out might have a soul. However, even if it does happen to have a soul at that point, won't it just go back up and look for a new host for its spirit? It was dead before it had any form of life. This, to me, is the same as having no baby in the first place. Babies are sometimes dead when they're born, that's not all that differant than abortion, its just a different form of death. If God wanted all babies to be born, why do so many die on their own? Look it's not an opinion, abortion is killing lives and taking away the chance for that baby to grow up and maybe even make a difference in someone else's life. Face it, i don't care if u think it's an opinion, a fact is a fact. Look freako, nothing is fact unless it can be proven with the scientific method. You say that killing a baby is taking away a chance for it to grow up, however, not having a baby in the first place not allowing it grow up. Same deal, dude. Just because I support the idea of abortion, I'm not a baby-murdering sociopath. I don't think that its good, I just think that people should have the option. Oh, and face it, just because an old book tells you its wrong doesn't mean that its so. Fact is fact. As far as Catian Theoretical and ryuu's ideas go, I agree. ryuu especially, I really should have said that in first place. You need a good reason to get rid of the baby. Also, abortion is one of those things that is your personal choice and shouldn't be controlled by other people. Its your baby that's not going to be there, not theirs'. Its your joy that you're missing when you get rid of the chance to have a child of your own. Its not their baby to miss out on. Just because some old method tells you it is true doesn't mean it is. Fact is fact. I would say that if both the Mother and the child were going to die then you might have to chose both to die or one to die. Unless there was a miracle at the last second. In the case above you would ultimatly have to choose one. Me personally, I would pray for confermation or a miracle if a situation that serios came up. If the mom just had sex without thinking of the consequences then she shouldn't abort it, she should deal with the consequences.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 30, 2006 5:29 pm
Quote: Look it's not an opinion, abortion is killing lives and taking away the chance for that baby to grow up and maybe even make a difference in someone else's life. Face it, i don't care if u think it's an opinion, a fact is a fact. Indeed, abortion is killing a fetus, and taking away it's chance to grow up. Yes, that is fact. But it's your opinion that abortion should be made illegal. Quote: I only think that abortion should be done in the case of rape or incest, or if the mother's life is in danger. Then again, I'm a little tired of people using abortion as birth control. THAT makes me angry. A new life is growing, but will never have the chance to make something of that life. Human life, to me, is sacred, even if it's just a few cells when you first look at it. Killing anything that will grow into a baby, into another human being, is wrong to me. That doesn't mean I'm going to the nearest abortion clinic and damning the murderers to hell. My views differ from theirs, and pro-choice and pro-life will never quite see eye-to-eye. In fact, there's a big to-do going on in my state (South Dakota) over this very issue. *sigh* My personal idea on it: Make abortion clinics into places you go when referred by a doctor. For one, if it's not readily available as a walk-in, more people might have safer sex. For another, you'll need a legitimate reason to get rid of a child. Course, that would probably be protested too. I agree that you should need a legitimate reason, but I think the choice should be available to everyone. I hate the idea of someone getting an abortion on a whim, but you just can't restrict the people who can get abortions because it would make it harder for people who do have legitimate reasons and anyone can walk into an abortion clinic and say they were raped so I don't see this as a very good idea. Quote: Yep, supporting the deposing of ruthless dictators and terrorists just can't happen when you value innocent human life. If you're pro-war or pro-death penalty, you're not pro-life you're pro-innocent life. I'm pro-choice and I'm anti-war, and I most certainly don't support the death penalty. I'm pro-choice because I don't think the state has a right to control women's uteruses (uteri? I'm sorry I fail at spelling right now). I'm against the death penalty because I don't think the state has the right to decide who lives and who dies. And war is just stupid. People are murdered and tortured for nothing, because there really is no such thing as war for peace. Look at the Iraqi death toll, are all of those people ruthless dictators and terrorists? Quote: Do u know that ppl don't go to a pregnant woman and ask "How's ur fetus doing?" they ask her "How's ur baby doing?" or "did u feel the baby kick yet?", ppl use "fetus" when the baby is unwanted or when talking about abortion but when it's wanted it's called a baby, i wonder why ..... *wonders* Because when it's wanted it's going to become a baby, and fetus is the correct scientific term. The phrase 'unborn child' is an oxymoron, really. Either it's a child or it hasn't been born yet. Quote: We wont remeber, but that doesn't mean it does not think. The highest proof I find that a body does not live unless a spirit is in it is the jellyfish. With no brain, heart, blood, bones, or lungs, and yet it eats and moves. That shows living things need a soul to really live. The baby would not find a new "host" it would be dead. It would most likely be in Heaven. A soul must be there to live. When the soul is part of the flesh is a mystery to me. So you think animals have souls? Me too. -shakes hand- I can't imagine why a fetus would be sent to hell. And it's a scientific fact that we don't think during the early part of the pregnancy, there is no gray matter and therefore the fetus cannot acheive cognition until later. Just an idea I came up with about thirty seconds ago, maybe the soul enters the body when it comes to the point of viability when it can survive without the mother, when it becomes seperate from her. More likely is at the moment of conception, when the DNA plans are laid out. But it depends on what you believe a soul is. Is it the energy, the life force within us? Or is it like our DNA, what makes us--well--us? Or is it our mind (not brain, mind)? I suppose that would influence when you thought the soul enters the body, but if you said it was like a combination then we'd be back at square one. Quote: Supporting pro-choice and the death penalty? Kill off those innocent children, but let the murderer live. I resent that, not everyone who recieves the death penalty is guilty and everyone who recieves the death penalty is capable of concious thought.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Aug 30, 2006 5:39 pm
Abortion is one of those subjects where it's hard for me to decide where I stand.
I guess I vote (or will vote, anyway, when I turn 1 cool pro-choice. It's not my business what others do. And I understand there a circumstances which I cannot understand right now which an abortion seems right.
Personally, I'm pro-life. I wouldn't abort. In general I think it's a last resort kinda thing. If you can't support the baby, I would rather see it given up for adoption than killed.
It's also a subject I don't know a whole lot about, so I really don't have much backing for either side. sweatdrop
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|