|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Dec 31, 2006 5:47 pm
Reason to Live - An Essay
Recently I've been noticing more and more people walking around with their hands in the air, asking, "What point is there in living?" Even more recently have I realized how much this scares me, for when I see them asking the reasons for their lives, I also see the question that they do not put into words; "Why should I live? Why not lie down and die?" To be quite honest, it shakes me to the very core of my being. Do they truly care so little for their lives? "Why should I live?" It is most certainly a question we've all asked of ourselves, and sometimes even of others, at some point in our lives. It's human nature to question the reasons for everything, so of course it's a natural question to ask. And, given man's social nature, just as natural is the desire to call upon others for aid and guidance. This is good and right, as it deepens the bonds between people and, once they are certain of their reasons for living, gives people a reason to strive and a reason to hope. During the brief (or perhaps not so brief, as all men must grow and learn at their own paces) time that every person searches for the answer to this question, their lack of this knowledge can cause them more misery than anything else they may encounter in their lives.
Yet this short duration of misery is far more than worthwhile, for once this answer has been discovered, a person can find more hope and faith in themselves than ever before. This is what scholars and writers and philosophers refer to when they speak of the unconquerable human spirit. It is this very pride in life that gives men the spark, the drive, the will to attain their dreams, no matter how far away they might seem.
But what of those questers who, instead of asking others for guidance, plead for answers? What would become of them, they who cannot find their own, unique reason for living? What would they become? Most likely, failing to see the beauty and purpose of life, many turn to self-mutilation, and, in turn, to suicide. But what of those who cannot even summon the courage to let go? What sort of hopeless monstrosities might they become?
They become lost souls, drifting through a life of undeath, praying, waiting for the void to take them. These damned ones can be easily distinguished by way of the dull, glazed veil of death that rests eternally in their eyes. This is not to say that they are easily perceived by their manner, for the actions of these walking dead often take form in the shape of that which they most desire to attain.
The majority of those who appear the most frivolous and joyful amongst humanity are often these very lost souls, playing through a horrific farce in the vain hope that it will bring them the joy they feign. It will not, and can not. Such joy can only be attained by the ordeals endured to learn the realization of the self. Suffering must be experienced in order to fully understand and appreciate the measure of joy. Happiness is not given freely, nor does the world give it frivolously, as these souls believe. Happiness, while enjoyed by every living individual in their own manner, of their own making, is a thing earned, not given.
So to those who walk about with their hands in the air, asking, "What point is there in living?" I say to them: "That, my friend, is something that only you can discover. If you so desire, I will serve as your willing advisor, but this is a path that only you can walk, and it may only be walked alone. I wish you the best of luck on your journey."
I already know my reason for living, unlike so many I have met who are still searching. I live solely for my own happiness, and that, my friend, is an end unto itself.
"I swear, by my life and my love of it, that I will never live for the sake of another man, nor will I ask another man to live for mine." -Oath taken by those entering Galt's Gulch, from Atlas Shrugged by Ayn Rand
"Ex nihilo nihil fit." -Latin for "Nothing comes from nothing."
I posted this in my journal a few months ago, but since then I've revamped it and submitted it to my school's lit mag as well as this one. It's not really a short story (personally, I think it's an essay), but it's here because it's not a poem and has no chapters, so, well... Here it is! Enjoy!
I'd like to see your reactions to this, as well as your differing views. Bye for now!
To Sepik: I just figured that I'd christen this subforum, too, while I was at it. Enjoy! ^_^
-Aurah
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Jan 03, 2007 7:07 am
I sorely feel I’m not in a position to comment this text, but since no one has so far I will try to, because not only do I think that it would be contradictory for a piece to remain un-commented in this guild, but there are some points which rather disturbed me when I read.
Formally, your writing is impeccable; the structure is smooth and drives one to the point you’re trying to make nicely. It’s the contents that shook me, for it looked like a much too light and carefree approach than what the thematic demanded.
I had a Philosophy teacher once that always insisted that we used certain words when talking about a certain subject. Oh, I tried used synonyms but when the papers returned they just came with a large red strikethrough over them. That’s when I realised that each word has an essence of its own, and synonyms are only approximations that can give a completely different tone to a sentence. For example, your questions, especially “why should I live”: these are all such casual words arranged in such a casual manner. To me, it gives the impression that whoever is asking this has already decided that he doesn’t want to live. Almost like when your mother tells you to go out with her and you don’t want to, so you ask “why should I go?” - only one word in difference but supposedly a world apart in depth. In any case, this would mean that all those “people walking around with their hands in the air” you refer to are suicidal - which I find rather disturbing.
Also, I’m not completely sure I agree with the point you’re trying to make. “Most likely, failing to see the beauty and purpose of life, many turn to self-mutilation, and, in turn, to suicide. But what of those who cannot even summon the courage to let go? What sort of hopeless monstrosities might they become?” That’s very harsh, and very demeaning. So you’re saying that those who can’t find the answer to what is possibly the greatest philosophical question do not possess an “unconquerable human spirit”? And since this is an essay and not fiction, I think it’s matters to say that I don’t agree in the slightest. Seeing the beauty of life and seeing its purpose are two very different things; one does not imply the other.
Well, I’d prefer to leave it at that. I’m sorry if that’s harsh or offensive, but like I said - this grim perception on people disturbed me and I just had to say something.
Happy writing! wink
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Jan 05, 2007 3:26 am
That's perfectly fine. I tend to find that I am a pessimist and always seem to have a very dark view of things, and this is reflected in both my writing and my cynical, often sarcastic personality, especially in real life.
I agree 100% that all words have their own essence and meaning. There really are no such things as synonyms, and knowing these differences and being able to use the "perfect" word rather than the "pretty good" word makes a good writer into a great writer.
A good example of this is the difference between "plummeted" and "dove". "Dove" is not only typically voluntary, it also tends to imply grace and perhaps a bit of lightness, whereas "plummeted" often is used to describe a faster, more violent fall, and is used in a darker context. However, if one were to look these two words up in a thesaurus, they would be considered synonyms when they are, in fact, very different.
I intentionally made the question "why should I live?" seem a bit flippant to impress a point; many people seem to ask the question without wanting to actually consider all points of it. They tend to want a quick answer without too much thought to the full connotations of both the question and answer.
By the way, your words are not harsh or offensive in the slightest; rather, I find them a compliment as they demonstrate that you have given thought to my views rather than merely skimmed over them without considering the message I attempted to convey. Truthfully, I don't mind that you disagree with me on some points; I didn't and don't expect anyone to agree with me on everything. Personally, I believe that everyone should be allowed to express their views without fear of persecution. This contrast of viewpoints is what makes writing so beautiful.
Thank you for giving so much thought to my work. Bye for now! ^_^
-Aurah
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Jan 06, 2007 7:28 pm
Thank you for being so gracious about it. I'm always extra careful since I've had a few relatively bad experiences in the past. Well, I'm an incurable optimist most of the time (I don't do weekends or hollidays u_u), so our views here would necessarily be different.
And I agree that healthy discussion is a great thing. Sadly, people seem to think it's impossible to discuss differences in opinion and not turn it into an angry fight over which is best or truer. Especially over the internet; impersonality must make them bolder in defending their 'personalities'!
But I ramble. Agreeing to the generalization or not, it was an interesting text. One would be hard-pressed *not* to give further thought to the matter after reading it, so that must mean you've done your job well as a writer. ^^
C-ya! wink
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Jun 24, 2007 4:20 am
The concept of life and death is always a touchy one, and even more so when it comes to suicide. I congratulate you for addressing this topic with dignity and a sense of, well, sensibleness.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|