Welcome to Gaia! ::

I don't fear it but I can see why others do

I would say that the obvious answer to that is that not everyone is really comfortable with incest, fictional or not. It's such a taboo thing in real life, that a lot of people (I might even say MOST people) can't quite come to terms with even reading it. Chances are the friends who didn't like this wouldn't react any better to Fred/George, Lucius/Draco, or any of the other incest pairings that HP fanfic authors so adore. Do your friends even like slash, for that matter? MY best friend isn't a homophobe or anything, but when we used to write LOTR fics, she could never quite come to terms with the fact that I always wrote slash.

Personally, Sirius/Regalus isn't one that particularly interest me, because it's fairly obvious in the books that Sirius holds his brother in contempt, and I love my canon.

Still, if it was well-done, I'd read it.

Well, I've got a couple beer in me (I'm legal), so my brain is a little too fuzzy to read it all right now, but I bookmarked it, and I'll definitely keep reading later. 3nodding

I enjoyed the first chapter, and I like the fact that Sirius and Regulus don't seem to hate each other as they do in so many other stories. Also, the fact that it's told from Regulus' POV. And the title is awesome. ^.^

My friend got me hooked on Sirius/Regulus. Though how Regulus is portrayed is what makes me decide I like a fic or not. I imagine him to be the shy type. Though I'll admit that I did not like them at first, I warmed up.

I can't say I've seen this pairing before. I also have formed opinions about Regulus being shy and such, so that would also have a lot to do with if I liked the story. I'm usually willing to try anything at least once, so I would read one. But I couldn't say if I would like it. Truthfully, I think some things should be the same as in the books and Sirius' hate for the Blacks is one of them. Another thing is I just have to be in the mood to read something like this. I like Fred and George, but only when I'm in the mood. Therefore, "on the fence"

I have hereby decided that I like this pairing! Thanks for the fiction, thatdrncat! You wrote that very well, in my opinion, despite all the nit-picking I did in the reviews. sweatdrop

that comic is hysterical! I loved it!