|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 Posted: Sun Jul 29, 2007 9:51 pm
WARNING:!! This thread MAY and probably WILL contain spoilers! Please put all your spoilers in WHITE FONT and put a warning before them in your post. To see the spoilers, just highlight the text.
With that out of the way, has anybody read the last book? I finished it the day of, and I have to say, I'm rather pleased but at the same time, slightly let down. I'll leave spoilers out for now though to see who all responds. ^^
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Sep 01, 2007 8:14 pm
3mi WARNING:!! This thread MAY and probably WILL contain spoilers! Please put all your spoilers in WHITE FONT and put a warning before them in your post. To see the spoilers, just highlight the text.With that out of the way, has anybody read the last book? I finished it the day of, and I have to say, I'm rather pleased but at the same time, slightly let down. I'll leave spoilers out for now though to see who all responds. ^^ AHHH i HATED the ending, she completely gave up, and just left everything in ruin scream
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Sep 01, 2007 10:07 pm
DORYUU 3mi WARNING:!! This thread MAY and probably WILL contain spoilers! Please put all your spoilers in WHITE FONT and put a warning before them in your post. To see the spoilers, just highlight the text.With that out of the way, has anybody read the last book? I finished it the day of, and I have to say, I'm rather pleased but at the same time, slightly let down. I'll leave spoilers out for now though to see who all responds. ^^ AHHH i HATED the ending, she completely gave up, and just left everything in ruin scream Which part exactly? The whole "I killed Voldy by making him drop his wood!" part or the 19 years later? Please dont say the 19 years later. XD I hated the 5 pages of talking about battle leading up to the whole two lines of spells. The epilogue I have no problems with tho
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Sep 03, 2007 10:26 am
3mi DORYUU 3mi WARNING:!! This thread MAY and probably WILL contain spoilers! Please put all your spoilers in WHITE FONT and put a warning before them in your post. To see the spoilers, just highlight the text.With that out of the way, has anybody read the last book? I finished it the day of, and I have to say, I'm rather pleased but at the same time, slightly let down. I'll leave spoilers out for now though to see who all responds. ^^ AHHH i HATED the ending, she completely gave up, and just left everything in ruin scream Which part exactly? The whole "I killed Voldy by making him drop his wood!" part or the 19 years later? Please dont say the 19 years later. XD I hated the 5 pages of talking about battle leading up to the whole two lines of spells. The epilogue I have no problems with tho ok, this post contains MAJOR spoilers, please dont read if you dont want to... just by the events that happened you can tell she gave up, like for instance what happend after they broke out of gringotts?!? was it just magically repaired?!? what happend at the ministry after they stormed out of there!?! better yet, what happend at the ministry after harry deffetet vouldemort!?! was it just magically normal again, where did umbrige go? what happend with azcaban? what about the dementors still running amuck across the world. what ever happend to the school? its almost completly distroyed, grand staircase blown up, a whole wing of the castle demolished and sudenly its normal again? how did everyone appear in the room of requirement at the end? i know they cam from that pic entry thing, but how did ALL of them apirate there without sounding the alarm that harry did, and even if by some miricale the alarm didnt allert the death eaters of there pressince, wouldnt they have noticed all of them going into that shop and none of them leaving, cuz there were a TON of them; the whole DA, the Order of the Phinix, all the 7th years that ran off, even harrys old quidich team, and rons whole family, WHO WOULDNT NOTICE THAT! and speaking of all the 7th years that ran off, did you not notice that NONE of them graduated school? and half of the 6th years missed that year too. Nevil has basically kicked out of school, then suddenly he is a professor?!? how did that happen!!! plus the final battle like you pointed out had 3 pages full of random talk and 2 lines of spells, ohh and not to mention when harry was wandering the woods, there was a WAR going on right behind him, his freinds were DIEING!!! but no, she ignored at least 90% of that and talked about how hard it was for him to wander those woods.... ohh, and the ending of the book a 4 year old could have guessed after reading the first book... i liked the ending and all, but i completly hated it at the same time becouse, at least to me, it seems like she GAVE UP and wanted to end the series...
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Sep 03, 2007 7:42 pm
DORYUU 3mi DORYUU 3mi WARNING:!! This thread MAY and probably WILL contain spoilers! Please put all your spoilers in WHITE FONT and put a warning before them in your post. To see the spoilers, just highlight the text.With that out of the way, has anybody read the last book? I finished it the day of, and I have to say, I'm rather pleased but at the same time, slightly let down. I'll leave spoilers out for now though to see who all responds. ^^ AHHH i HATED the ending, she completely gave up, and just left everything in ruin scream Which part exactly? The whole "I killed Voldy by making him drop his wood!" part or the 19 years later? Please dont say the 19 years later. XD I hated the 5 pages of talking about battle leading up to the whole two lines of spells. The epilogue I have no problems with tho ok, this post contains MAJOR spoilers, please dont read if you dont want to... just by the events that happened you can tell she gave up, like for instance what happend after they broke out of gringotts?!? was it just magically repaired?!? what happend at the ministry after they stormed out of there!?! better yet, what happend at the ministry after harry deffetet vouldemort!?! was it just magically normal again, where did umbrige go? what happend with azcaban? what about the dementors still running amuck across the world. what ever happend to the school? its almost completly distroyed, grand staircase blown up, a whole wing of the castle demolished and sudenly its normal again? how did everyone appear in the room of requirement at the end? i know they cam from that pic entry thing, but how did ALL of them apirate there without sounding the alarm that harry did, and even if by some miricale the alarm didnt allert the death eaters of there pressince, wouldnt they have noticed all of them going into that shop and none of them leaving, cuz there were a TON of them; the whole DA, the Order of the Phinix, all the 7th years that ran off, even harrys old quidich team, and rons whole family, WHO WOULDNT NOTICE THAT! and speaking of all the 7th years that ran off, did you not notice that NONE of them graduated school? and half of the 6th years missed that year too. Nevil has basically kicked out of school, then suddenly he is a professor?!? how did that happen!!! plus the final battle like you pointed out had 3 pages full of random talk and 2 lines of spells, ohh and not to mention when harry was wandering the woods, there was a WAR going on right behind him, his freinds were DIEING!!! but no, she ignored at least 90% of that and talked about how hard it was for him to wander those woods.... ohh, and the ending of the book a 4 year old could have guessed after reading the first book... i liked the ending and all, but i completly hated it at the same time becouse, at least to me, it seems like she GAVE UP and wanted to end the series... I get what your saying on a lot, like the whole "What happened after" thing. And this definately doesn't make up for it, but JKR is planning on writing an encyclopedia next of all that happened after. Like Kingsley being made Minister. I hate how everything was so predictable too. AND THE CLICHES! I swear to god, I skipped the entire Prince's Tale chapter after reading about the childhood friends thing. I know JKR loves to base things off Shakespeare, but Lily/Snape was a ******** cop out of Romeo/Juliet and pissed me off. And Harry being a horcrux pissed me off. EVERYBODY, even people who didnt READ HBP, could tell he was one. But, overall, all my ships came out, so I can't complain too much on it. It's my favorite and least favorite book of the series
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2007 8:01 am
3mi DORYUU 3mi DORYUU 3mi WARNING:!! This thread MAY and probably WILL contain spoilers! Please put all your spoilers in WHITE FONT and put a warning before them in your post. To see the spoilers, just highlight the text.With that out of the way, has anybody read the last book? I finished it the day of, and I have to say, I'm rather pleased but at the same time, slightly let down. I'll leave spoilers out for now though to see who all responds. ^^ AHHH i HATED the ending, she completely gave up, and just left everything in ruin scream Which part exactly? The whole "I killed Voldy by making him drop his wood!" part or the 19 years later? Please dont say the 19 years later. XD I hated the 5 pages of talking about battle leading up to the whole two lines of spells. The epilogue I have no problems with tho ok, this post contains MAJOR spoilers, please dont read if you dont want to... just by the events that happened you can tell she gave up, like for instance what happend after they broke out of gringotts?!? was it just magically repaired?!? what happend at the ministry after they stormed out of there!?! better yet, what happend at the ministry after harry deffetet vouldemort!?! was it just magically normal again, where did umbrige go? what happend with azcaban? what about the dementors still running amuck across the world. what ever happend to the school? its almost completly distroyed, grand staircase blown up, a whole wing of the castle demolished and sudenly its normal again? how did everyone appear in the room of requirement at the end? i know they cam from that pic entry thing, but how did ALL of them apirate there without sounding the alarm that harry did, and even if by some miricale the alarm didnt allert the death eaters of there pressince, wouldnt they have noticed all of them going into that shop and none of them leaving, cuz there were a TON of them; the whole DA, the Order of the Phinix, all the 7th years that ran off, even harrys old quidich team, and rons whole family, WHO WOULDNT NOTICE THAT! and speaking of all the 7th years that ran off, did you not notice that NONE of them graduated school? and half of the 6th years missed that year too. Nevil has basically kicked out of school, then suddenly he is a professor?!? how did that happen!!! plus the final battle like you pointed out had 3 pages full of random talk and 2 lines of spells, ohh and not to mention when harry was wandering the woods, there was a WAR going on right behind him, his freinds were DIEING!!! but no, she ignored at least 90% of that and talked about how hard it was for him to wander those woods.... ohh, and the ending of the book a 4 year old could have guessed after reading the first book... i liked the ending and all, but i completly hated it at the same time becouse, at least to me, it seems like she GAVE UP and wanted to end the series... I get what your saying on a lot, like the whole "What happened after" thing. And this definately doesn't make up for it, but JKR is planning on writing an encyclopedia next of all that happened after. Like Kingsley being made Minister. I hate how everything was so predictable too. AND THE CLICHES! I swear to god, I skipped the entire Prince's Tale chapter after reading about the childhood friends thing. I know JKR loves to base things off Shakespeare, but Lily/Snape was a ******** cop out of Romeo/Juliet and pissed me off. And Harry being a horcrux pissed me off. EVERYBODY, even people who didnt READ HBP, could tell he was one. But, overall, all my ships came out, so I can't complain too much on it. It's my favorite and least favorite book of the series ok, ill agree with you there, it was my favorite one of the series... BUT I HATED IT!! lol rofl and you can all ready tell the movie will suck... haha they are going to cut out the whole middle part of the book for the movie razz that part was boring...
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2007 12:06 pm
DORYUU 3mi DORYUU 3mi DORYUU 3mi WARNING:!! This thread MAY and probably WILL contain spoilers! Please put all your spoilers in WHITE FONT and put a warning before them in your post. To see the spoilers, just highlight the text.With that out of the way, has anybody read the last book? I finished it the day of, and I have to say, I'm rather pleased but at the same time, slightly let down. I'll leave spoilers out for now though to see who all responds. ^^ AHHH i HATED the ending, she completely gave up, and just left everything in ruin scream Which part exactly? The whole "I killed Voldy by making him drop his wood!" part or the 19 years later? Please dont say the 19 years later. XD I hated the 5 pages of talking about battle leading up to the whole two lines of spells. The epilogue I have no problems with tho ok, this post contains MAJOR spoilers, please dont read if you dont want to... just by the events that happened you can tell she gave up, like for instance what happend after they broke out of gringotts?!? was it just magically repaired?!? what happend at the ministry after they stormed out of there!?! better yet, what happend at the ministry after harry deffetet vouldemort!?! was it just magically normal again, where did umbrige go? what happend with azcaban? what about the dementors still running amuck across the world. what ever happend to the school? its almost completly distroyed, grand staircase blown up, a whole wing of the castle demolished and sudenly its normal again? how did everyone appear in the room of requirement at the end? i know they cam from that pic entry thing, but how did ALL of them apirate there without sounding the alarm that harry did, and even if by some miricale the alarm didnt allert the death eaters of there pressince, wouldnt they have noticed all of them going into that shop and none of them leaving, cuz there were a TON of them; the whole DA, the Order of the Phinix, all the 7th years that ran off, even harrys old quidich team, and rons whole family, WHO WOULDNT NOTICE THAT! and speaking of all the 7th years that ran off, did you not notice that NONE of them graduated school? and half of the 6th years missed that year too. Nevil has basically kicked out of school, then suddenly he is a professor?!? how did that happen!!! plus the final battle like you pointed out had 3 pages full of random talk and 2 lines of spells, ohh and not to mention when harry was wandering the woods, there was a WAR going on right behind him, his freinds were DIEING!!! but no, she ignored at least 90% of that and talked about how hard it was for him to wander those woods.... ohh, and the ending of the book a 4 year old could have guessed after reading the first book... i liked the ending and all, but i completly hated it at the same time becouse, at least to me, it seems like she GAVE UP and wanted to end the series... I get what your saying on a lot, like the whole "What happened after" thing. And this definately doesn't make up for it, but JKR is planning on writing an encyclopedia next of all that happened after. Like Kingsley being made Minister. I hate how everything was so predictable too. AND THE CLICHES! I swear to god, I skipped the entire Prince's Tale chapter after reading about the childhood friends thing. I know JKR loves to base things off Shakespeare, but Lily/Snape was a ******** cop out of Romeo/Juliet and pissed me off. And Harry being a horcrux pissed me off. EVERYBODY, even people who didnt READ HBP, could tell he was one. But, overall, all my ships came out, so I can't complain too much on it. It's my favorite and least favorite book of the series ok, ill agree with you there, it was my favorite one of the series... BUT I HATED IT!! lol rofl and you can all ready tell the movie will suck... haha they are going to cut out the whole middle part of the book for the movie razz that part was boring... The movie is DEFINATELY gonna suck. It'll be too long to include everything, so me and my friend made a list of everything that will be cut out, no doubt: -The life and times of Dumbledore -Rita Skeeter -Ron's splinching -The majority of the Ron/Hermione moments -The preparation of Bill's Wedding, as well as the ceremony -The cafe -Kreacher maybe. It depends if they put in movie 6 who RAB is -Tonks/Remus and Teddy -Snape's Memories. It'll just include the main point -Going with that, probably Snape's patronus. Harry will just magically stumble upon the sword or it will be in gringotts when they go to get the goblet of Hufflepuff and they steal them both -MAYBE Dobby's death or the whole Hermione torture part, which means Harry wont activate the Taboo. I'm SLIGHTLY hoping they dont do the Epilogue, because it'll ruin it for me to see another actor being older Harry, Ron, Hermione, Ginny, and Draco.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2007 1:00 pm
3mi DORYUU 3mi DORYUU 3mi Which part exactly? The whole "I killed Voldy by making him drop his wood!" part or the 19 years later? Please dont say the 19 years later. XD I hated the 5 pages of talking about battle leading up to the whole two lines of spells. The epilogue I have no problems with tho ok, this post contains MAJOR spoilers, please dont read if you dont want to... just by the events that happened you can tell she gave up, like for instance what happend after they broke out of gringotts?!? was it just magically repaired?!? what happend at the ministry after they stormed out of there!?! better yet, what happend at the ministry after harry deffetet vouldemort!?! was it just magically normal again, where did umbrige go? what happend with azcaban? what about the dementors still running amuck across the world. what ever happend to the school? its almost completly distroyed, grand staircase blown up, a whole wing of the castle demolished and sudenly its normal again? how did everyone appear in the room of requirement at the end? i know they cam from that pic entry thing, but how did ALL of them apirate there without sounding the alarm that harry did, and even if by some miricale the alarm didnt allert the death eaters of there pressince, wouldnt they have noticed all of them going into that shop and none of them leaving, cuz there were a TON of them; the whole DA, the Order of the Phinix, all the 7th years that ran off, even harrys old quidich team, and rons whole family, WHO WOULDNT NOTICE THAT! and speaking of all the 7th years that ran off, did you not notice that NONE of them graduated school? and half of the 6th years missed that year too. Nevil has basically kicked out of school, then suddenly he is a professor?!? how did that happen!!! plus the final battle like you pointed out had 3 pages full of random talk and 2 lines of spells, ohh and not to mention when harry was wandering the woods, there was a WAR going on right behind him, his freinds were DIEING!!! but no, she ignored at least 90% of that and talked about how hard it was for him to wander those woods.... ohh, and the ending of the book a 4 year old could have guessed after reading the first book... i liked the ending and all, but i completly hated it at the same time becouse, at least to me, it seems like she GAVE UP and wanted to end the series... I get what your saying on a lot, like the whole "What happened after" thing. And this definately doesn't make up for it, but JKR is planning on writing an encyclopedia next of all that happened after. Like Kingsley being made Minister. I hate how everything was so predictable too. AND THE CLICHES! I swear to god, I skipped the entire Prince's Tale chapter after reading about the childhood friends thing. I know JKR loves to base things off Shakespeare, but Lily/Snape was a ******** cop out of Romeo/Juliet and pissed me off. And Harry being a horcrux pissed me off. EVERYBODY, even people who didnt READ HBP, could tell he was one. But, overall, all my ships came out, so I can't complain too much on it. It's my favorite and least favorite book of the series ok, ill agree with you there, it was my favorite one of the series... BUT I HATED IT!! lol rofl and you can all ready tell the movie will suck... haha they are going to cut out the whole middle part of the book for the movie razz that part was boring... The movie is DEFINATELY gonna suck. It'll be too long to include everything, so me and my friend made a list of everything that will be cut out, no doubt: -The life and times of Dumbledore -Rita Skeeter -Ron's splinching -The majority of the Ron/Hermione moments -The preparation of Bill's Wedding, as well as the ceremony -The cafe -Kreacher maybe. It depends if they put in movie 6 who RAB is -Tonks/Remus and Teddy -Snape's Memories. It'll just include the main point -Going with that, probably Snape's patronus. Harry will just magically stumble upon the sword or it will be in gringotts when they go to get the goblet of Hufflepuff and they steal them both -MAYBE Dobby's death or the whole Hermione torture part, which means Harry wont activate the Taboo. I'm SLIGHTLY hoping they dont do the Epilogue, because it'll ruin it for me to see another actor being older Harry, Ron, Hermione, Ginny, and Draco. wow, that movie is really going to suck... eek
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2007 6:31 pm
DORYUU 3mi DORYUU 3mi DORYUU 3mi Which part exactly? The whole "I killed Voldy by making him drop his wood!" part or the 19 years later? Please dont say the 19 years later. XD I hated the 5 pages of talking about battle leading up to the whole two lines of spells. The epilogue I have no problems with tho ok, this post contains MAJOR spoilers, please dont read if you dont want to... just by the events that happened you can tell she gave up, like for instance what happend after they broke out of gringotts?!? was it just magically repaired?!? what happend at the ministry after they stormed out of there!?! better yet, what happend at the ministry after harry deffetet vouldemort!?! was it just magically normal again, where did umbrige go? what happend with azcaban? what about the dementors still running amuck across the world. what ever happend to the school? its almost completly distroyed, grand staircase blown up, a whole wing of the castle demolished and sudenly its normal again? how did everyone appear in the room of requirement at the end? i know they cam from that pic entry thing, but how did ALL of them apirate there without sounding the alarm that harry did, and even if by some miricale the alarm didnt allert the death eaters of there pressince, wouldnt they have noticed all of them going into that shop and none of them leaving, cuz there were a TON of them; the whole DA, the Order of the Phinix, all the 7th years that ran off, even harrys old quidich team, and rons whole family, WHO WOULDNT NOTICE THAT! and speaking of all the 7th years that ran off, did you not notice that NONE of them graduated school? and half of the 6th years missed that year too. Nevil has basically kicked out of school, then suddenly he is a professor?!? how did that happen!!! plus the final battle like you pointed out had 3 pages full of random talk and 2 lines of spells, ohh and not to mention when harry was wandering the woods, there was a WAR going on right behind him, his freinds were DIEING!!! but no, she ignored at least 90% of that and talked about how hard it was for him to wander those woods.... ohh, and the ending of the book a 4 year old could have guessed after reading the first book... i liked the ending and all, but i completly hated it at the same time becouse, at least to me, it seems like she GAVE UP and wanted to end the series... I get what your saying on a lot, like the whole "What happened after" thing. And this definately doesn't make up for it, but JKR is planning on writing an encyclopedia next of all that happened after. Like Kingsley being made Minister. I hate how everything was so predictable too. AND THE CLICHES! I swear to god, I skipped the entire Prince's Tale chapter after reading about the childhood friends thing. I know JKR loves to base things off Shakespeare, but Lily/Snape was a ******** cop out of Romeo/Juliet and pissed me off. And Harry being a horcrux pissed me off. EVERYBODY, even people who didnt READ HBP, could tell he was one. But, overall, all my ships came out, so I can't complain too much on it. It's my favorite and least favorite book of the series ok, ill agree with you there, it was my favorite one of the series... BUT I HATED IT!! lol rofl and you can all ready tell the movie will suck... haha they are going to cut out the whole middle part of the book for the movie razz that part was boring... The movie is DEFINATELY gonna suck. It'll be too long to include everything, so me and my friend made a list of everything that will be cut out, no doubt: -The life and times of Dumbledore -Rita Skeeter -Ron's splinching -The majority of the Ron/Hermione moments -The preparation of Bill's Wedding, as well as the ceremony -The cafe -Kreacher maybe. It depends if they put in movie 6 who RAB is -Tonks/Remus and Teddy -Snape's Memories. It'll just include the main point -Going with that, probably Snape's patronus. Harry will just magically stumble upon the sword or it will be in gringotts when they go to get the goblet of Hufflepuff and they steal them both -MAYBE Dobby's death or the whole Hermione torture part, which means Harry wont activate the Taboo. I'm SLIGHTLY hoping they dont do the Epilogue, because it'll ruin it for me to see another actor being older Harry, Ron, Hermione, Ginny, and Draco. wow, that movie is really going to suck... eek And you know whats worst? It'lls be a lot less violent because they'll want to keep the PG13 rating
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2007 7:34 pm
ugh... cutting out all the violence... gonk
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Sep 05, 2007 9:39 am
DORYUU ugh... cutting out all the violence... gonk Not nessicarily all. I figure if they can get away with the Cedric and task parts in GoF and the cutter quills in OotP, they'll atleast have SOMETHING good. You know what I've noticed though? NOBODY is as excited for the HBP movie as they were all the others. XD Nobody likes Half-Blood Prince
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Sep 05, 2007 12:30 pm
3mi DORYUU ugh... cutting out all the violence... gonk Not nessicarily all. I figure if they can get away with the Cedric and task parts in GoF and the cutter quills in OotP, they'll atleast have SOMETHING good. You know what I've noticed though? NOBODY is as excited for the HBP movie as they were all the others. XD Nobody likes Half-Blood Prince lol its couse everybody thought it was dark
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2007 3:11 pm
Gah, I was very dissappointed by it
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2007 3:39 pm
Shades_of_dust Gah, I was very dissappointed by it by which... the book or the movie, lol
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Sep 09, 2007 3:42 pm
DORYUU Shades_of_dust Gah, I was very dissappointed by it by which... the book or the movie, lol Both lol. The most recent movie was very bad, they masacered the book
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Reply
